NFTs in Science William Entriken https://desci.nyc/transcripts/nfts-in-science Automatically generated transcript. May contain errors. [0:03] cool all right well thank you guys all for um Coming Out I appreciate you making the journey um out here um for those of you that don't know this is a DSi NYC which is um [Applause] I think this is like the fifth one that we've done so far themed guests from Martin shkreli to a guy who's indexing all of the mushrooms and the world to a guy who studies the blood brain beef area the barrier the blood-brain barrier in bees um to we've had so many different speakers and um we're always looking for more speakers so if you have [0:44] recommendations um let us know um DSi NYC I think is probably one of the leaders in the decentralized science movement so um we're connected now with Desai Tokyo and the Desai London and Desai Tel Aviv and decide Berlin and we're trying to create like a bit of a network in the decentralized science community um and it's going well and so I was happy to have all the people all you here with us and so what is decentralized science um it sort of comes from the Insight that I think we can make science more fun um with the blockchain partially we can [1:24] make science more uh reliable using the blockchain we can make science more democratic with the blockchain we can make science uh be more equally funded and giving more people the opportunity to participate in science um with the blockchain and it's sort of rethinking is like how we had D5 which was like potential is finance took over traditional Finance maybe we can do the same thing with decentralized science where each piece of data or each researcher is a token and has a reputation and can be swapped and loaned against for the benefit that the idea is sort of like when there's a lot of eyes on something um you have you can create something that's sort of better and more [2:05] transparent um I will talk a little bit about the projects that we're working on which is um the DB dial and dimidao is kind of like a air table for web3 and it's used by a lot of decentralized science projects um so I'll just give you a quick demo of how it works here it's very similar to like the way airtable looks so we have people that are using it to catalyze catalog every butterfly in the world which is super cool so someone creates a butterfly um species and then they send this link out to everyone in the entire world and um then the people then fill out this form and every form every road every butterfly species that's created is [2:47] actually like an nft and that person is the owner of that data that data point and what's cool is um so now they send this form out to people and they say like oh I found a monarch because I'm from Santa Cruz monarchs and um then you can see when they created this Monarch they you can go to openc and you can buy and sell this individual piece of data and uh you can see it has provenance on Avalanche it's stored on ipfs but so that's an example of how it's used but it's also being used by like other types of people as well so here doll uses DB dial and this is like really cool because hair now is insight into decentralized science was that [3:29] there's some researchers out there who are trying to do study hair loss and there hasn't been a lot of research in it since like 1997 and but there's Reddit communities of hundreds of thousands of members out there that are interested interested in in this subject and the idea is like they can do clinical trials much more cheaply than Pfizer or some other things but also um the people that are participating in this are much more motivated to uh because they're sort of they're not just being paid they're they're actually they actually care about it um so uh that's one key person who's using it another one is so this is the [4:10] interface that they built another one is Ulta Flora so they're using uh dbdao to test out CBDs effects on kids with epilepsy so this is something that like the FDA would never probably touch but unlike some of these forums parents have found that CBD helps children with epilepsy a lot and they're doing this like clinical trial to um just to make sure that that it works so that's kind of it how that works and so what's cool is like when the way it works is like everyone puts in their data and then a a drug company or someone comes to buy this entire data set and when they buy the data set for like a million dollars or something the [4:52] money is then split out to everyone who contributed a piece of a row of that data set so it's a way of democratizing how wealth is sort of distributed um we can we can encrypt things we can do the revenue if you guys are interested in working together if you have a science project we have someone here is working on nootropics we have someone here who's interested who's doing it for social science uh reach out here and uh and connect out so thank you guys um he had a group picture here yay oh yeah [5:32] um smile everyone yay but if you want to get here can we do a selfie yes I take it what do you think okay um okay so we have this amazing space here and there's this cool company called um free agency and uh they have this really innovative business model where each person should have their own agent uh on their behalf who works to find them the best job so join us you're hired yeah so first thing you guys are coming I'm Joe from free agency with previously is is we bring Hollywood style representation to Tech town so just like your favorite actor actress or athlete as an agent as on the back end [6:14] of their career we do the same for yours so we are the Jerry Maguire of startup and Tech Talent so what does that mean it means uh if you guys are hiring please reach out to us if you're looking to host more events always welcome you know for the community and if you're looking for your next opportunity feel free to reach out as well and with that that's back to okay and Joe's been super helpful um he's they've hosted many of our events here they host a lot of Stanford alumni events and they're always very um they're not like it's it's fun to host it here like some of the other places you posted they're like but here it's like very chill and relaxed and it's like a home and uh it's [6:54] like a bedroom or a dorm you know it's kind of like a door party it's like a lounge [Applause] thanks uh hello everyone I'm Ray and really glad you guys are here this is a tech nine for everyone and um yeah uh I'm the independent researcher for DSi and also a contributor for like um DB Dao the database and also I'm an opportunity investor right now and I met uh William like kind of last year and [7:36] his father yeah he's been like they are amazing and they're like William is the um lead author of prc721 it's a basically the standard of nft so I feel like it's really special to have William here because during the nft week in acting NYC is like his birthday right so a big plus to William thank you [8:12] hi everybody I'm will enter Ken uh no invest in this room for nft I'm the lead author of this document called erc721 back in the day this explains what is an nft and if you're making nfts then you're following the specification so thank you unboxing uh just some other boat winners out there maybe there's some people in here so I'll just get some introductions I worked at Google for a minute in the New York office remotely a long time ago starting my career in open source this is actually what kind of brought me into blockchain is because my experience is creating open source communities and creating mentorship programs at open source communities and then years later I found blockchain that's how I got in I worked at the US Navy for a minute and I I do [8:53] business in Philadelphia in Shanghai so just a quick Factor about me and today's talk is nfts in science this is a broad discussion this is pretty entry level nothing's expected of you we're coming in here and we're gonna have questions too at the end so I just wanted to talk about an important part of data dials nft is in science specifically data permission the permission to use data okay bear with me for a minute I'd like to show you a very close-up photo of a cervical cancer biopsy from 1951. [9:28] [Music] it is scanning electron microscope photo so this photo is a biopsy um that's an XKCD reference all right so this is the most copied cell in biology this is how you're looking at it right here this cell is used everywhere it is a human cancer cell from 1951 and it has so many applications in biology it's used for polio research cancer AIDS anything that has a something that's got to be tested with DNA or whatever this is the basis across biology and because it's a human cell and humans are often [10:10] the things we're trying to cure right this is the most important cell in biology did it come from it came from Henrietta Lacks Henrietta Lacks presented to John Hopkins University in 1951 after childbirth with some pain in the womb doctors took a biopsy from the cervix and found this cancer cell which they then passed around to other doctors and if you've ever done cancer cell research typically a nice warm sample will last three or four days what they found is that this sample lasted a lot longer it persisted it is the first immortal cell does anybody know telomerates foreign [10:51] so when cells divide there's this thing at the end there's there's code in a Cell that's a technical as we're getting there's code and DNA the end of it doesn't matter and when you cut it a bunch of times the end kind of trails off this one doesn't you can keep cutting it and make perfect copies forever so this is the first immortal cell line really important great commercial applications people made a lot of money off of this and they found out after days weeks years this cell was just going so strong we're still using it today billions in dollars of sales of this so now now her descendants are coming back and they're saying well wait a minute oh key part of the story where [11:33] the cell came from never got consent from her to use this or sell this cell now this was 1951 there's a couple things you needed about 1951. one black people were given free medical care in John Hoffman University and there was a segregated system back then and they did different things then that they don't do now two it was common practice to take the cells without permission you would never do this now and the people that are selling her cells acknowledge that they wouldn't do this now but they're doing this now so these are two things you need to know about history okay so now her family comes in and says well wait a minute we would like to be participating in the decision making of the usage of [12:14] these cells oh and guess what they're descendants so it's also their cells too if you've ever signed up for 23 me or your dad or your mom or your grandparent that's you too so you're all signed up in this video together so if her family has a stakeholder if they're stakeholders in this cell line and they're talking about participating in science is this the first data down this is the first and largest data down it's this cervical cancer cell from 1951 they're currently selling they're currently suing Fisher for 250 billion dollars in back payment move back royalties on [12:55] this cell and then there's one of about 47 lawsuits that they're currently working on so you know go strong right they've got a great negotiator on this but I want to tell you about this because this is very this is a doubt decentralized autonomous organization who was decentralized it is the family members autonomous nobody else is telling them what to do and they're organized they're very organized so the best way to understand the world is to compare the things that you already know this is from 1951 no technology needed to understand here can we use nfts for data permission so I wanted to talk about let's formalize this so we've got we've [13:37] got family members and they've got permissions there they would like to permit usage of these they're called um healer cells that's the name of this this stuff they just abbreviated her name Kayla uh Henrietta blacks right tequila cells and so every time that these are used legitimately with the family's consent they tokenize that and by tokenized that I mean they write it down in a record they put it in a ledger this is an nft it is a unique item and a pleasure I mean it can be written on this chair and it could be in Excel it could be written on a piece of paper that's a ledger that is an nft we can also do nfts on the blockchain that's cool too [14:18] formalizing further we need to be able to prove that these tests we have to prove these attestations there's a permission granted so if you are using this cell for research and you are permitted by the council you want to know that if you're doing an Ethics Committee review with your school and they're like oh yeah we don't want to use stolen cells from somebody civil rights issues from 70 years ago and you're like oh no they approved it how many times have you had to prove to your ethics Council where you got your stuff from right I hope no well that's a problem guess what that's changing and we're going to start demanding these things now this is a pretty high profile cell so if [14:59] they say it's true and they they put on their website that's gold but for some of these less visible projects you want to have that somewhere blockchain a website anywhere an email chain that you can copy paste and prove but you want something so I just want to formalize this uh these these attestations when you have permission to use this data it may or may not be transferable n of T is may or may not be transferable nfts can be on blockchains nfts can live in a Cell a very practical guy I want these applications to work so I'm not telling you use blockchain or ethereum or c721 I just want you to make better [15:40] systems and attribute where attribution is due who do science Dallas benefit well in this situation we've got her family right and they want two things one is they would like money for all the money that was made off of the cells and two they want to say in where this research is used they say oh we want you to run it by us why are you using these cells what types of outcomes are you working on we want to know many people now that they're aware of this there's been documentaries and books on this and they'd like to give credit we want to celebrate the success of this woman who unwittingly donated unwittingly gave these cells right and [16:23] helped polio AIDS vaccines all types of things were possible because of this and this family has an interest in just recognizing that so that is a beneficiary of attribution of data in science I've got a specific application but quick a little survey please raise your hand if you are of European descent okay please keep your hand up if you identify as white okay this is science so we can say these things okay if your hand is up you are over represented in pharmaceutical research you are overrepresented in DNA research and therapies that are based on DNA that is a problem if your hand was [17:03] down you are an opportunity to improve farming that's what I'm working on here's an example this is something I did with a client not current client this is called somos this is a DNA test kit this they've got to Booth it and that's the NSC so here's what this is it works exactly like and it um works exactly like 23andMe you open it up there's a test kit now there's some laws in the US that are done that say you have to give your name when you give DNA which we interestingly work around by having a default name and when you do this your name is using this does anybody know what this is [17:46] seed phrase okay these are 12 words I designed this I prayed with all this so this is a crude and well-known system but it works for creating identity digitally and when your status comes back you can decide where your data is used now this system is specifically for people of Latino descent in South America specifically indigenous folks indigenous so they have a very strong concentration of a specific gene pool which is great for farming farmer loves this they would love to have more diverse things so that [18:26] when they launch their drugs they don't just kill everybody because their sample population is so overrepresented by some Europeans they want to have more indigenous specific people this allows that now we're not just taking our data we are allowing them to participate and they have visibility and traceability all the way down supply chain let's go right so let's do this type of stuff in more places um this is just one Mighty example of what is possible with data downs and supply chain traceability of data specifically DNA all right looking at another example [19:07] there are other types of ways that nfts can benefit science I looked at an example molecule now there's some specific things on here uh so I say good things I say bad things so what we're looking at right here is different specific research projects which you can also be a stakeholder in the way this one is working is they're more interested in in the money their mission says molecule is creating liquid and easily investable assets now I also checked the SEC website and I did not see them registered in Edgar so watch out for that um the SEC is currently five years behind on bringing lawsuits so if this was less than five years old you know be careful all right so good [19:50] luck uh watch out for that but these are all I'm not saying this is a bad thing I'm just saying I'm very practical guy so I don't want you to be in jail I haven't been in jail does that make me not an injury so you know I want these things to work I want different types of stakeholders to be represented in science the ethics so biotech Innovations raise ethical questions every time so we need to study the different stakeholders I don't have the answers for you but what I can say is if you have more stakeholders more diverse stakeholders you will get probably more answers maybe not even like you'll get more answers and hopefully if you if you're smart you can get better answers we can have ownership and permission at [20:32] least visible I'm not saying it's going to be better I'm not going to say we're going to solve these problems but we're not going to right but it will be a little better that's what we're that's what I'm going for it's better okay privacy and security these are things that blockchain does not specifically solve however if you have something that's valuable like DNA access that other people don't have and you pay for it maybe you're going to keep it secure because you paid for it if you're going to have something and you went through an Ethics Committee and you paid for it right you have this data why would you put it on uh lip side right when everyone else is going to publish first right so what did you [21:13] publish get your stuff out there and this have this rare commodity you're using okay and now there's a downside when you use Downs unlike the Hella cell line when you have a lot of when you have a lot of participants with diverse opinions in it now something you need to watch out for is a lot of times we talk about doubt we're just doing majority voted or quadratic voting which is not quadratic and these are the all right you guys know that it's cool so we're using this is the other one second quadratic funding that's the other one quadratic funding right so these approaches mean if there's if there's a voting system which is a consensus mechanism [21:56] more General awareness consensus in the way the building quadratic so if you have a consensus mechanism especially if it's enforced on chain that means some people their vote will not be the way that this thing goes so they're submitting there's a they are submitting to the outcome is this a rule by committee human cooperation Robert's Rules and committees have been studied forever and there will be some people that are not happy with the outcome that's just something you could know that's different than having every person individually make a decision they're making a consensus just saying watch out for that so this is me come up here and I'll be happy to talk about this anymore but [22:36] also have a weekly call to go into these high level topics but also much deeper technically on things that you're doing I have a little Cube that you can pick up a little Domino on the table and this is my weekly call thank you [Applause] one more thing so getting a little more technical I did want to bring some original research today and give you something that we could take them and use for data science now we're getting nerdier all right let's go so this is something on GitHub I've got code let's talk about this this is a simple template [23:17] for SQL databases who doesn't use who does not use SQL for your data science okay let's go who uses who uses graph for data science in medical research zero no one okay let's see this is an example of a SQL database running sqlite did you come around locally and I've got a demo up here so come on up I'll show it to you but not ones not on the screen where everything that you do creates an audit Trail result so every record that you put in every record that you modify has an ID and these ID is add up does anybody else know another type of database that has immutable records that are append only blockchain blockchain we've stolen the [23:59] most important part of blockchain and just brought it down to SQL which is what we're already using so this example shows you how to do that automatically with triggers to Nerdy with triggers so that you can have an append only database append only databases some of the magic things with blockchain that you know how do you quickly summarize information in a blockchain where you can expose some of the information but not all of it how do you summarize anything cash it you can hash it what is hashes of hashes Merkle root Merkel hashes Miracle trees so this allows us to have a database where we expose some of it [24:39] and again you don't need blockchain if you're working in big Pharma you don't need to prove you don't need to go to legal and say we're going to do a blockchain project you go to your data people and like we're going to do a SQL project and that's how you get things pissed you take the smallest knife and you you know you make an incision so I've got an example of that of where if you've got these blockchain ideas and you actually want to use them do them with your existing team don't go through legal and reviews if you're anybody's in big company here you know I make these Solutions happen too so I want to give you the tools of the easiest things I've got a little GitHub repo but you can study that you can play it if you use Mac it has SQL three SQL Lite three built-in you don't have to download anything anything you can show up here and you can check out yourself [25:24] [Applause] wow what an amazing talk um well I think we probably have questions for I know I have a lot of questions but um does anyone have any questions on The Talk I'll start um okay so you you hash the entire date I don't like that last thing so you hash the entire data set and um how do you confirm that that hash hasn't been mutated by someone else so how do you like say you replay the whole thing you still need to have you still have that hash where you need to prove that you haven't tampered with that so we have we have attestation but we also require digital security so in stealing ideas from blockchain how [26:05] does blockchain provide digital security tied to an identity consensus no how does blockchain how do you know that the blockchain records are authentic and created by the people that they say they're created by how do you verify that feature it's a signature we use digital signatures how do we know that those digital signatures tie back to people that we care about yeah the IDS how do you publish the IDS on blockchain but no not on blockchain how do you make the credential verifiable certificate Authority [26:46] yes how do you know which website Google is on oh DNS DNS so you're using this we use a centralized registry as these techniques are also applicable to databases we can use DNS to store signing keys and when you can use these signing keys to sign databases which we publish anywhere we can sign hashes anywhere all the technology exists and does not require blockchain use blockchain it's great but I also want to say that these ideas are so simple that we can get them done anywhere yeah no excuses oh yeah so you were saying skip the [27:27] legal review so I was wondering what you meant by that just create a product and you skip the regulatory stuff I've worked on a lot of projects on very big organizations I helped Ernst young work with Microsoft to change the way that they record royalties on Xbox I worked with French brands that are 200 years old that make watches change how they authenticate their their merchandise they change literally change the certificate of authenticity I've seen watch companies that have been around for 200 years that are French you know anything about French people allow a customer to be intermediated by a third-party company these are really tough things to do you [28:10] don't want to try that hard if you can get something done faster than that the minute that you say we're going to deploy a blockchain project at a Pharma company which I've also done Merck animal health uses blockchain in production for drugs they sell friends right so these things work they're in production but when you're selling it internally don't be like hey we're going to launch this thing on ethereum and be like nope you'd be like hey we're going to add audit trails to our databases they're going to say we don't have Auto trials on our databases you're like no you forgot to turn that on an sap turn it on on that same thing that's the first step to hashing your databases [28:50] providing a testation so all these things can be done with your existing resources but the magic is you know what happens when we have a database that we sub hash so that we're not publishing databases we're hashing the publishing hashes that we signed do you know how powerful that is we know what happens when you do that but these are very small asks hey um we want data Assurance for our internal business records that's an easy yeah we don't have a data insurance for our internal business no you don't you need to Hash your databases we need to have insurance assurances for our customers when they buy our stuff but these are only we don't have assurances for our customers when they buy our stuff these are legitimate no we need to published [29:31] hashes and sign them so these are the way that you ask your operational people with the agenda that you have in the back of your mind that you're going to be really pushing forward these ideas by the time you're done you've introduced assurances for your records attestations verifiable records 99 of blockchain and you get all the benefits and you're just doing good business stuff that you should have been doing anyway just use different words and you avoid the lawyers if you if you want them to say no faster don't say don't say blockchain say we want to use Bitcoin so like is this all being done to like get people into uh sort of architecture where they could [30:12] eventually use a public network or do you actually just think that the benefits of using a public network for these attest Nations doesn't matter in order to deploy the public network at a large organization organizations that matter I'm not saying small doesn't matter but that matter you know the ones that are going to be on point desk that are going to be you know on the New York Times right those organizations in order to deploy these type of data down stuff you will still have to do all these steps anyway difference is either you're asking hey I want to make databases with audit Trails do attestations hash things and make customers be able to audit our stuff and deploy an ethereum based roll-up ZK proof Network [30:54] it should all just be built into postgres at once yeah right or I want to ABCD so you're getting the same place but I'm just getting you there faster with a way more practical and smaller steps it's also very likely that you won't need that last step because I'm the first person to tell you you don't need nfts on blockchain I tell every client they're like I want to do this they said hey we want to improve inclusion of different ethnic groups in pharmaceutical research and we want to use nfts I'm like yes maybe and you know we had to use this card yes okay they made me do it this way but you can get this to Market faster without blockchain good enough so all I care about is improving medical [31:36] outcomes for a diverse population of people is that that's it that is their mission I support that and they just happen to want to do ABCDEF all at the same time which is good too all right it's probably a silly question nope which part of this is actually the the c721 part so where is where does that come into yep where is what is stored there the data permission is the nft so non-fungible token if you don't know non-fungible means a number and token means worthless it is a worthless no that is what an nmt is the reason why people like nfts is because they represent other stuff I got [32:17] an idea in my pocket that's got a number I've got a car title that's my car ownership I care about the car which number is it does anybody know the number on their car title registration no you don't care it is not an important it is a worthless number but what if that number represents your ownership ownership permission to use data in a experiment or in medical research well that is the same number that you need to give to your professor to sign off on your research because if they look that number up and it doesn't if it's 404 not found you're not getting fun or they're gonna be like uh try again bro you need to give me not give me something that's [32:57] wrong so that number is going to log in somewhere it's going to check a thing and it's going to connect to a green check mark that says Yep this University is approved for this thing to be used on this project and you're just going to connect does that make sense yeah that makes sense and so users get to because it's their nft they get to like at what point do users um come through and say where do they get to send their permissions that's something the permission comes from the so same way the permissions always come from the person that has it to the person that's paying for it this is intellectual property this is the same exact model we use for licensing Xbox games on Microsoft platforms to [33:38] people that are buying it when you don't buy games you license games so the data the data is in the nft nope okay permission that's the permissions just the permission okay then you can use token getting that is a very specific word you don't have to do a token key but you will have access to the data obviously after you pay for it by whichever mechanism but your authorization which you prove to other people is this number you can look it up just like a pattern you have a pen so the pattern is the country grants you exclusive rights to commercially exploit a specific invention represented by a number so when you buy an Apple computer and this chair that's [34:20] patented for some reason there's on the bottom it says actual number 135. you look up that patent number you're like oh snap Apple does own the license the pen to make this shape of unibody MacBook Pro so you're not going to do that now if you type in that number and now that shows that we don't know why they're actually supposed to tell you if it's nice if it's patented right so these are that's the thing that's just it's just the pattern the patent is a extension of a permission data Dallas extension of preparation please all right one more question are you a fan of silver token yes uh unfortunately what's your definition Does it include [35:02] uh wrapable or only externally advocates sorry what what's your definition of Southern non-transferable yeah yeah okay this is cat and mouse game people make sold-bound tokens as a restriction because they don't want them to do something with their nft I know a great use case of somebody that wants to make nfts extremely popular artists that's working on this right now and she says I don't want anybody selling my nfts I want them to just do experience the thing that she does as an artist and not have a secondary [35:43] market for these nfts and that's a restriction so that's going to be yeah she's going to require that she's not going to do this project but that's not the thing right so that that is a requirement that the artist has now that is just a requirement so if that's not going to happen she's not going to participate in the system just like this data down for these immortable cell line they don't want you to use it for other purposes if they Grant you this nft for doing research about uh you know cancel research and they want you to do cancer research great but if you're going to do this research on some type of abortion and they don't like that type of abortion then they're going to say no [36:25] it's up to them to Grant it but you can't go in there and be like okay I'm going to do cancer research oh psych I'm going to take that and I'm going to give it to someone else and they're going to do whatever else well that defeats the whole purpose of them granting permission on a case-by-case basis so for them they would say sold down tokens only now there are possibly some ways to get around that and now it becomes a cat and mouse game so I won't go too deep into that excellent well with that [Applause] um for uh oh wait we have one more thing one more one more thing one more thing as a thank you again um to this um Beaker yeah that has uh that you can [37:08] measure your fluids in and it has the DSi NYC logo there so [Applause] um we have to go out of the building but um there's plenty of other things it's New York city so again we'll be doing this again next month I will send you an email all with uh details on how to attend that as well and yeah thank you guys again