ResearchHub Patrick Joyce https://desci.nyc/transcripts/researchhub Automatically generated transcript. May contain errors. [0:00] all right okay um [0:22] all right we're gonna get started so guys we have a lot coming up um all right all right all right let's turn off the music find a chair find a chair connect to the person who's next to you and tell them to find a chair Justin [1:03] oh there we go all right so if everyone you guys turns around this way [Music] I'm sorry [1:40] um [1:57] um [2:52] um [3:09] thank you [3:25] um [3:46] hi guys so everybody starts yeah okay so we are hosting a decentralized science Meetup welcome everyone thank you guys for coming to DSi NYC it's a pleasure to have you um thank you also to our co-sponsor tonight uh BBs for uh um also thank you to Ray our wonderful Seaside DB Dao Helper and product person and also thank you to Gunner who will be hearing more from in a moment thank you [4:37] okay so for those of you who don't yet know um decentralized science is about how you can use the blockchain guys if you're talking about okay if you guys of you who don't know um decentralized science is about how you can use the blockchain to improve science so that Paul talks about how you can improve funding how you can improve data how you can improve publishing all these types of things so tonight we're going to have some amazing things going on um firstly we're going to have a talk by research Hub and what research Hub is doing is they are changing the way we're doing publishing people are doing publishing using the blockchain and this [5:19] is very cool we're going to have Patrick here another he's the co-founder of research Hub the other co-founder of research Hub is Brian Armstrong the founder of coinbase so that will be very exciting and then secondly we're going to have the first ever Psy Doge Awards now the side Doge Awards recognize greatness in decentralized science so we have seven projects that have been carefully careful and I'm not joking we have actually gone over all the DSi projects and carefully looked at every single one of them and chose the seven best in each of the categories and we are going to recognize them here tonight and it's going to be a lot of fun Okay so [6:01] um just a thing about DSi NYC uh we have speakers once a month we've hosted people like Martin shkreli we posted the person who invented the nft we posted people um that are doing research on bees we posted lots and lots of things if you've missed any of them you can go to dsi.nyc all the videos are there and recorded um we also have this like group chat where we talk um so you can apply to be part of the group chat uh we try and keep it um key to people that are doing DSI or desire related things so if you're interested in that uh you can scan this QR code and apply there the the link is [6:42] also on the dsi.nyc page so if everyone's got that okay so the second thing we have um oh and if you're interested we're hosting another one this one will be this is the next DSi NYC event if you'd like to preemptively register for it we don't yet know who the speaker is but this is the Luma for it oh also thank you to Luma there they gave us free uh they give us like a free year-on research uh subscription so shout out to Luma they were very kind on that thank you Luma yeah um so uh if you're wondering if you want to go to the next one go to luma.lu.ma slash DSi nyc7 [7:28] okay cool um so this event is also sponsored by DB Dao that's the company we started uh TV that was like an on-chain database so every Row in the database is an nft that can be bought and sold um we have token gated access to that database so only if you hold a specific token are you able to view that data set and you're then able to sell the data in that data set and that data is then uh because if you then uh if you guys uh have the data then you're able to sell it to other people and gate it so if you have a data set of 100 of 100 rows and someone buys that data set for a hundred [8:09] dollars each of the people that contributed one row earn a dollar and this is very cool so uh TV dial if you're interested in learning more uh come speak to me come speak to Ray after the event or during or whenever um this is very cool this is the first time that this we've announced this this is like coming out um we've been doing these this is the sixth DC NYC thing uh event that we posted and we've had people come up and say hey we want to get more involved in decentralized science we want us we want to learn more we want to start our project I had this idea in my head that I want to that I want to start or I have [8:52] a company that I'm doing and I think it would be a really good fit for decentralized Science and people didn't really know how to get started so um we created this new program called side combinator and it's a four-week program where we're going to make cohorts we already have five amazing projects that have applied and have been accepted and we are now sort of opening it up a little bit more to make this an even more amazing patch of people so I don't think you're going to want to miss out on this first uh this first opportunity you're going to get amazing mentors you're going to get a demo platform we have funding if you guys want funding if it's like your full-time thing we can definitely work on that [9:32] with you guys and I think this is going to be like an important thing in creating more DSi projects in the ecosystem so if you want to apply if you go to SCI combinator.xyz it's a four-week program uh make sure to apply by June 15th although priority will be given to people that have their stuff together and apply early so uh don't miss out on that okay oh wait so um now what we're gonna do is we're going to have uh the research Mr research Hub come speak so to introduce him yeah right right hello guys uh I'm Ray [10:14] [Applause] [10:32] [Music] so I want to introduce Patrick at least uh founder of research Club he's a former PhD student he volunteer biology and the former Matt's student who dropped out of Academia to help the broken incentives of scientific and founding and Publishing so I want to introduce caption Michael yeah Patrick are you here Patrick are you here [11:52] there we go there we go all right all right Patrick is here um [12:29] thank you foreign [13:10] huge and just uh let me know whenever you guys want me to kick it off all right I think we're ready okay cool um yeah so first of all thanks for having me this is like a pretty impressive crowd so it's kind of great to see like the energy coalescing around the GCI space so uh big time shout out to Michael and relief for organizing everything this is really cool um yeah so I'm here today to talk about research Hub and the role of incentives into academic science um just a little background on myself my name is Patrick and I'm one of the co-founders and CEO of research um when I was in college I was a huge science nerd I was really lucky in that [13:51] I got to do undergraduate research at Johns Hopkins studying tumor biology in a hhmi-funded lab Howard Used Medical Institute it was like the perfect research environment for a young scientists um there's maybe 30 people in the lab it was extremely well funded the Pi had basically the freedom to explore the theories that he was most interested in and the result was an extremely like intellectual and curiosity driven workplace that was just a blast to be a part of um based on this experience I fell in love with research decided to do a PhD in mock your biology at Boston University and very quickly found that not all labs are quite as lovely to be a [14:33] part of as a hhmi-funded Hopkins lab um just to give like three specific stories that I think help to illustrate some of the issues that exist within academic research um the first rotation I did was in a lab looking at the development of drosophila embryos and there was maybe like a fifth or sixth year PhD student who had like multiple nature papers and had already been accepted to a postdoc at MIT and so this person was like The Golden Child of the pi and it became very clear from day one the way to succeed within Academia is about getting Publications in very [15:13] prestigious journals that you can then show off and use as like essentially evidence of your quality as a scientist um so that was the first lab where it was ingrained into me how important Publications were um the second experience I had was in a cancer lab looking at the epigenetics of pathocellular carcinoma um there's a grad student there who was kind of like the opposite end of the spectrum essentially they were in their ninth year of their PHD program normally phds like are five to seven years Max in microbiology at least and so this person had completely run out of funding um they were essentially like sleeping [15:54] on a friend's couch and paying for their own reagents out of their pocket in order to get the results they needed to like impress a subjective uh like committee uh to get the degree he needed to then go do a postdoc somewhere and make like just under fifty thousand dollars a year and so this was crazy to me because talking to this person um just one-on-one as humans they were really bright and hard working and like for whatever reason like the results just didn't fall their way and so they were stuck in a situation that um I was not very envious of and yeah like the last experience that I had in grad school that kind of like encouraged me that maybe academic science wasn't [16:34] the best career for me personally um was in a synthetic biology lab that was fascinating it was like one of the most interesting like laboratory experiences I've ever had um it was actually somebody doing early stage car T cells which are now uh like very like a big staple of synthetic biology and this person um was maybe in their mid to late 30s so technically still in the early career researcher um and they had had about as much success as humanly possible at that point in their career during their post-doc they had like two or three nature papers they were essentially one of the most like uh well-published early career researchers in their Department but regardless he still had to go [17:15] through the process of applying for a grant so there was maybe like six months while this like extremely successful early career researcher um was applying for an r01 where they were kind of walking on eggshells throughout the lab like essentially their whole career was tied to a group of phds in uh like Grant Review Committee um giving him the thumbs up to move forward with his research despite the fact that he's already demonstrated himself as a very talented researcher um so yeah this to me kind of like demonstrated that even if you're like at the absolute top of your field there's very little job security and the person [17:57] um basically told our lab that if they didn't get the grant like they had young kids in the area um they were going to have to move to a new institution pull their kids out of school and there was just a tremendous amount of like stress that had nothing to do with doing research that was put on this person purely based based upon the way that funding is distributed within academic research so it was pretty clear to me that kind of like the structure of funding and Publishing science like not only like wasted a lot of money but also with a lot of human capital and just really like quality of life for the average like academic scientists so I decided to leave with Masters started Medical School very interested in mental health and [18:38] Psychiatry and I was very lucky and got to go to Georgetown where like they place a huge emphasis on getting students into the clinic like almost immediately um so I got to see firsthand that like a lot of the medications that we use in psychiatry like they're really effective in certain subpopulations of patients but we use the same drug for um like anxiety depression PTSD OCD it's like 60 ish years old and across all of the patients that it's given to us a whole it's like slightly better than a placebo and so to me it was like what is going on here like this drug doesn't work that well kind of [19:20] our understanding of ways to treat psychiatric you know conditions don't work that well when you look in the pipeline of like what was new and exciting coming up for like anxiety depression um they were just like plants essentially it was like cannabis and uh like magic mushrooms and like natural products and not like a lot of like um lab derived Innovation and that's not entirely true it's kind of like a simplistic picture but it is kind of Representative and so I was frustrated by this I thought like hey like maybe part of the reason for this like lack of clinical therapy is this broken pipeline for funding and Publishing academic research so um I just had to take a year off uh you [20:02] know kind of ignorantly uh take a stab at trying to build my own company and so over the course of a couple years I ended up like raising a little bit of money um getting a V1 together but kind of like Reddit for science um at the same time Brian Armstrong the founder of coinbase published a Blog saying hey academic science is like pretty messed up like someone out there should try and build like a Reddit for science with like new token centers so I was like oh that's pretty cool like hopefully my parents will think I'm crazy anymore and uh I got in contact with him and we've been building a research Hub together for the past couple years now so it's kind of like background on how like I'm like approaching this problem and it turns [20:43] out that like there actually is a tremendous amount of waste in academic research I'm sure a bunch of people here are familiar with it and this kind of headline is a little bit hyperbolic in theory but yeah there was a famous paper in 2009 published in the Lancet where two um like big researchers essentially tried to claim that 85 percent of all research funding is wasted and so they've got the nice little uh Drive the point home uh sentence here that it's 170 billion dollars which is somewhere between the gdps of Kuwait and Hungary in 2009 and when you break this down this is the figure from that paper the authors like suggest a lot of reasons [21:23] why they think 85 percent of funding is wasted but it would kind of can be translated as a broken infrastructure for funding and Publishing research um essentially they believe that the grants that were funded are the projects that were funded were more kind of like intellectually interesting to the grant Review Committee more so than like driven by market incentives or really like how is this going to like push forward Innovation towards like a specific goal like treating depression and anxiety um the way that funding is distributed kind of hits researchers against each other so it's not like all of the uh neuroscientists looking at the effect of ssris in like people with general [22:04] anxiety disorder they don't like work together they kind of have this weird like Frenemy relationship where in theory like anyone who's working on the same problem as you can publish your ideas before you do and take away your credit and therefore your ability to get funding in the future so there's this like totally unnecessary competition that exists that's purely just like a downstream result of the way that we distribute capital and so like if um you know I'm competing with the person next to me on like the exact same like subject um how do I prove to the funder that I'm better than this person and like more worthy of their money [22:44] um essentially you publish in high impact journals like the first um kind of experience I described where if you have a couple major papers it's like pretty reasonable to go get a postdoc at a great institution you'll end up being a research Professor somewhere unfortunately this kind of like empowers certain for-profit publication entities um that will basically reduce reporting and in addition because it hurts scientists to have like a poor publication record um they just won't share results that aren't interesting so this results in the desk drawer problem where negative results will not be shared because like in actuality they're bad for your career [23:26] so there's no incentive for you to share them um at the end of the day like you can't even really blame scientists it's something like two percent of first year PhD students end up becoming research professors so the deck is stacked against everyone who's participating in the ecosystem and you almost have to try and engage in these behaviors in order to just have a chance at like a career in research um so yeah just like pulling back out from a high level view uh there's like a clear issue uh in today's scientific economy um everyone's familiar with the replication crisis not just in Psychology but in biomedical research as well and I'm sure lots of other fields where like at minimum 50 of research is [24:09] not able to be reproduced I've seen estimates as high as 85 percent of this as well I mentioned like the broken job market for or like well-trained academics and then the end result of this which is a hyper-competitive publish repairs culture um that wastes a lot of money for research funders so just wanted to take a second and Linger on the words of web3's favorite uh centenarian billionaire sometimes the solution to a behavior problem is simply to revisit the incentives and make sure they align with the desired goal so I'm going to follow his advice and look at an overview of the academic economy kind of like how I think of the [24:50] three major players here and what their incentives are uh the first is Grant givers who have money and what they want is new knowledge so I like to think of this as like the example Susan G Komen which is a breast cancer non-profit they collect donations um from people who care about breast cancer and they distribute those donations to researchers to try and come up with new knowledge to in theory like help the clinical treatment of breast cancer and then we have scientists who are actually doing the research um they have the ability to convert money into new knowledge and what they want is the ability to do so as I mentioned only two percent of first-year PhD students can become research [25:30] professors so there's a pretty big incentive for them to do whatever they can in order to get the capital required to do research and then finally Publishers are kind of the third entity they have distribution and what they want generally although this is kind of changing in the recent years is profit so they kind of you know engage in behaviors that in theory are like maximized by uh the company's bottom line at the end of the day um I think to like fully understand what's going on here it makes sense to take a second and like really empathize with a grant Giver so if you're Susan G Komen right you have a million dollars to give to uh [26:12] breast cancer research and there are five different research groups that apply to receive this million dollars of funding like what are you going to do how do you decide like who to give the money to that in theory has the best chance of giving you a good Roi on that funding and then eventually like improving the fight against breast cancer um so the issue is that it's basically impossible to holistically measure scientific quality there are plenty of examples where a very very important findings were not recognized until after the researcher's career kind of like artists to a certain degree and so we're kind of stuck with these imperfect like [26:52] metrics uh where we sort of like infer scientific quality or at least funders use these metrics to infer scientific quality and inform their own Grant making decisions um and so these are essentially called bibliometrics uh bibliometrics or citation based metrics are used to quantify researcher's productivity so how often they publish and then their impact so when they do publish how often do other researchers basically incorporate their science into their own work um in a way that it's cited within the second scientists eventual publication um the way that we actually measure this [27:33] in today's world is something called an impact factor this is kind of like getting out of Vogue a little bit now but it's a quality metric for a journal so it's the number of citations divided by the total number of papers uh within the journal and it's normally averaged out over a two-year period um we also have an H index um which is like kind of complicated to explain but it's more or less like a average number of citations per paper that you put out with some of the outliers kind of like softened away and so we're kind of presented with this issue when you think from the perspective of Susan G Komen scientists are really smart like they [28:13] understand that their work is being measured using these bibliometrics and since it's so competitive to even have a chance at success not even success just like a regular career within academic research you have to do whatever it takes in order to maximize your bibliometrics to become eligible for funding and so we're all familiar with good Hearts law as well where when a measure becomes a Target it's ceases to be a good measure anymore um so please excuse the outdated meme format here but this is like kind of what happens in actuality um in theory because funders signal that they want high impact factor Publications researchers are more likely to kind of [28:55] tailor their content towards what can more easily be published in a high impact factor Journal so instead of more original research that in theory could like help push scientists towards like a better treatment for breast cancer uh they publish editorials and review papers because it's lower effort and more likely to be published in a high impact factor Journal that will earn you a lot of citations down the road um at the end of the day uh these are kind of the behaviors which this like sort of bibliometric driven funding infrastructure uh encouraged within academic scientists um basically I mentioned an unhealthy competition that people will engage in [29:36] in order to get the most uh you know number of Publications they can um they're like weird things that people will do to try and maximize the impact or number of citations that their Publications have um they'll not report negative results they'll hypothesize after the results are known So in theory trying to find more interesting conclusions than they originally set out to find um and then of course they'll publish in paywall journals and help to create content for kind of rent seeking for-profit entities that disseminate scientific knowledge um and then yeah the downstream effect of this is like a really inefficient system and at the end of the day as [30:16] Susan G Komen I want to get the most bang for my buck and so the way that I'm currently Distributing uh research Capital through like grant-based traditional funding mechanisms uh ends up wasting me money because I'm incentivizing good people who just want a career in science to do not good things just to like have a chance at surviving within this publisher Parish culture so I think this is a great quote that kind of like summarizes sort of what's going on today um today I wouldn't get an academic job it's as simple as that I don't think I would be regarded as productive enough and so we all know Peter Higgs he did the theoretical work for the hex books on [30:56] um he has a publication record where it's a little bit more high impact and like less frequent so we have like 10 or so minutes left so just FYI okay cool yeah I can uh kind of like flow through the end here and get to questions um yeah basically the big picture is that like and people talk about blockchain a lot like as a hammer looking for a nail right but here in Academia we have like a like old school funding structure that creates a bad incentive system for participants and in this case blockchain is actually like a great tool in order to help solve these problems and so to talk about what we're building at research Hub kind of the the [31:37] V1 of our product is like a stack Overflow for science um people can post papers uh they can outvote them they can comment on them um you can publish original content so we have like a electronic lab notebook where people can share like non-research or previously published research paper type of content we have someone who likes to summarize and annotate all the human lab podcasts um you can ask questions from other scientists so we have a bounty feature where you can use the research coin you earn on the site to help incentivize specific content creation so this is a Pharma like uh investor who wanted to do interviews with neuroscientists in order [32:19] to get a lay of the land and you put out 10K research coin batteries and hopped on a couple interviews like within a few days in addition people uh have asked questions from other scientists to help improve protocols and help them actually like get research done in the lab and then finally you can earn tokens for sharing your knowledge and so just like one example of this I want to highlight um we're kind of doing peer reviews on bioarchive papers so here's one that I did over the weekend where I shared a peer review had a couple of questions about the results and I think within like two days yeah so one day ago I asked the question put a 2.5 k RC bounty [32:59] on it within a day uh there's an expert who basically provided more context and so yeah you have the ability to like earn tokens for sharing your knowledge um in the future uh we want to build like kind of GitHub for science functionality and then eventually get into funding um here's our team very lucky to work with Brian uh Kobe's a former selfies engineer Pat worked at Apple for a little while here's our foundation um then yeah I'll leave everybody with this quote but uh if anybody have any questions I would love to talk more thank you [33:40] um does anyone have any questions you can come up to the mic and come speak come on up [33:56] how close okay so you said that people can like self-publish research through your site how do you deal with like bad science like pseudoscience ideas overcrowding good science yeah so we're still very early um we haven't even had examples of like low quality research that would be published in like a paper mill or something like that um kind of we have had like essentially spammers so people who are using like LMS to just try and coin Farm um but the way we've tried to combat against this is by hiring editors um which are kind of like uh academic [34:36] moderators who earn research coins and salaries for a lack of a better term um in order to essentially help to grow each individual Hub or like scientific field and then help to moderate so if there are low quality papers um we have an expert who can essentially like remove them um and if it's like a kind of a paper Millie type of situation where it's unclear if it's quality content um we can put peer review bounties on them so in theory like the community can decide for itself like what is quality what's not quality yeah yeah quick question can you hear me yeah [35:19] cool um so I'm I'm curious why a system like archive that's free wouldn't be enough to incentivize people to publish research if you can publish say on archive uh and then if it attracts enough attention then you'll have enough of a name to publish future papers uh so that's question one and then question two is uh how much today do people get from research coin to is it enough to fund a salary and and how do you incentivize the the token to have any value [36:00] yeah so great questions thank you um the first one is an awesome one like archives are amazing repeat the questions also yeah sure so uh the first question was like why is archive not enough you know why does there need to be I guess like a crypto incentive on top and um the second question could you I'll do the first question first and then remind me in a second um the first is that like archives been around for a while uh bioarchive Med archive have also um they're definitely like great options for sharing of research in the open but in practice um it's really hard to get funding if [36:41] you just publish like a preprint um and that doesn't end up resulting in some kind of like high Prestige publication and so while in theory it is like a good solution for the publishing side of things it doesn't really fix sort of the financial reward infrastructure that encourages academics to um partake in behaviors that result in the replication crisis so at the end of the day the real issue is that you need to financially reward scientists for producing high quality research not necessarily like what is measured to be high quality and once that happens it would be sustainable um to participate in uh what kind of [37:23] open science practices um because even in archive you're still publishing a whole paper it's not like a live feed with open data um where people can comment on your experimental methods along the way okay and then what was the second question I always have those cool yeah so right now why not archive [Music] so right now there's a couple utility statements within the token um you can take people for the content [38:08] you create um you can create research coin bounties so uh in theory like if a preprint is shared and you want a peer review on it you can uh incentivize another scientist to do so um so in theory we've had like people buy research quote because they want to have feedback about the projects that they're working on or help with some of the methods that they're trying to create in their own lab um we're also building a couple features right now so we're planning to build a reference manager um where in theory like we'll have sort of like a freemium tier of features that help scientists like organize their literature and write it um and that could uh have people State [38:49] the research coined in order to use but we're still pre-product Market fit like very much so as I mentioned like we haven't even approached the problem of like kind of Quasi low quality research yet so we're still experimenting on like what the real value prop is for research coin and more so like research hubs application uh where we'll start to see organic growth and then like in theory we'll build tokenomic uh mechanisms around that value all right one more question so so I have two related ones um so I guess the first one is what about your platform and just the nature [39:30] of like decentralization makes it such that you don't just replicate the same problems academics have within like an institution type of like academic uh research um so like that's the first question of like what about research Hub actually fixes the problems you're trying to solve um because I could still see a situation which somebody's you know incentivized to do uh bad research but instead of grant money it's RSC um and the second like follow-up question on the flip side is like how do you communicate like if you're actually able to solve these problems and generate better research how do you communicate those like that like reality to the larger in like institutions like [40:12] Academia at large so that they actually get so you actually get buy-in so you actually so you actually like it's acceptable to cite a paper that's posted on your research Hub as like something that you could put on any type of publication um and I guess the third question which is more fun you don't have to answer it is what's your storage stack like is it decentralized uh yeah yeah no so these are all great questions uh just write them down and make sure there's a storage cool um yeah thank you these are awesome questions probably some of my favorite ones um the first one I think is extremely important which is like how do we know that we're not just going to recreate the same like bad incentive structure that already exists [40:53] um I think it's like pretty easy to look at like social media in general and realize how like there are these weird like incentive structures that kind of emerge over time uh that encourage like uh you know not necessarily bad behavior but like not exactly what you thought at the beginning and so um this is kind of like the third use case for racer coin which is um I think like slightly less compelling to the average um non-power user but uh essentially we can have Community voting around the reward algorithm and the reputation algorithm so uh the way we think about this is the way we reward content on Research Hub is dynamic and will change [41:34] into perpetuity because in theory like the financial incentives that would encourage the best behavior when our communities kind of like small and ragtag and like early career grad students is way different than it would be like when you have like a solid representation of all of Academia which would be way different than like if you had like half of Academia and the world changes all the time so the beauty of this approach is uh you can let people uh have a say in how they're rewarded and understand that like the rewards will change over time so instead of um like having a measure that's become a [42:14] Target we can just acknowledge that like hey we've got a Target and we're going to move this thing until you know we end up getting the best results um all the time so that's a few minutes left so just answer them quickly okay sure um the second one is uh I guess how do we gain legitimacy uh within regular science like uh the Ivory Tower so to say um we've actually had like a lot of open science organizations reach out to work with us um because they're thinking through these incentive problems as well and they see tokens that's like a powerful way to encourage healthy research behaviors so I think like once we find product Market fit uh there's ways to find win-win relationships with [42:54] organizations who do have like a good reputation within Academia um in order to like have some of their shine rub off or rub off on us um because we're hopefully helping them accomplish their mission as well and then our storage stack yeah so research Hub right now is kind of like web 2.5 um are like the way our web app is built is essentially the same as Reddit so it's like Amazon uh you know S3 web servers contain all the data um people accrue research coin on the site kind of like uh like Karma essentially and then you can withdraw this Karma to ethereum um we chose this structure because it's uh cheaper to ship new features [43:36] um when the database is centralized so our plan is to essentially find product Market fit see what the actual value of research Hub is and then build like a decentralized back-end kind of over time as a secondary priority to like providing value to scientists uh awesome awesome well let's all thank Patrick [Music] [Applause] Brown if you'd like uh we're going to move on to the cytos prize Well actually you should stick around to the side of the prize that would be good all right yeah sounds great um [44:17] all right so [Music] all right so now we have [44:38] [Music] oh [Music] so we can still be here yeah and then just put him in the corner okay yeah all right so now we have uh Gunner and Gunner is an artist in New York City who I've actually known for many many years and his paintings are rich and absurd in humor and pop culture so he has this one painting that is about Nicholas Cage is that Nicholas like cage and we'll show it to you in a second here on the screen [45:19] and you can actually he has a new gallery that he's just recently renovated himself and it's all pitch black and very cool and interesting so you should also go down to see it it's in Chinatown uh underneath the Manhattan Bridge and this Friday from six to eight you can see his grand opening for his store and there's free booze there so give us a round word of Applause for gunner [45:54] here we go ladies and gentlemen welcome to the annual ceremony of the side Doge prizes the only science award show where we break more rules of physics on stage than in our own research now before you rush to go check you're in the right place remember at our award show not only do we celebrate the mind-betting marvels of scientific discovery we also honor the countless coffee spillages failed experiments and then notoriously rebellious paperclude sculptures that make the journey to those discoveries okay okay [46:35] so tonight we are here to celebrate folks who have turned the ordinary into the extraordinary we took the phrase to the Moon quite literally our steam Lord It's haven't just made achievements in science they've also made significant gains in the value of their Dooms and wallets I'm your host for the night and no I'm not a product of AI or blockchain technology uh there's sometimes I wish I was celebration my luck could probably end up block head chain whoa at this momentous event we salute the Einstein Securities the mutants but also the oops the what the and of course the [47:15] Timeless Eureka you remember the light bulb moments literally the moments when the lab lights flicker as we all know it's time to evacuate uh but amidst all the silliness remember science is the key to unlocking the mysteries of the universe and so tonight we raise our beakers petri dishes and buns and burners and it toast the wild wacky and wonderful world of science we applaud our brilliant laureates who makes science a little less intimidating and a whole lot more fun today we will be handing out seven Awards in the categories of physics medicine chemistry economics math literature and peace [47:58] oh yeah here we go slides and peace um okay first up is physics physics physics is first here we go so prepare for a relative spike in your adrenaline as we Quantum Leap into the realm of physics next the honored Minds we don't just gravitate towards success they also accelerated us into the new era of understanding let's wave our hands high for these luminaries as we pull back the curtain to reveal the side Doge prize for advancements in the field of physics tonight's winner hasn't just been shooting for the Stars they've been [48:38] on the hunt for our Cosmic neighbors there's elusive aliens in the UFOs this side Newt award for advancement in physics goes to drum roll echoing Across the Universe future folklore.com [Music] all right so and we have also have you a toast with these custom Desai NYC cups amazing oh wait wait come over here and then well I'll get a picture together and then a dumplings all right so we'll get a picture here [49:26] all right and then ready cheers yeah [Applause] [49:50] because our next winner has roots that run deep in the field of medicine that they've tussled with tradition they've brushed up against the unknown and they have truly let down their hair to bring us groundbreaking work in medicine get ready for a hair-raising round of applause as the side Doge prize for advancements in medicine goes to drama hair down [Applause] [50:25] oh yes and this is your champagne so there's medicine hair down all right three okay we're getting a picture of three two one okay [50:52] another show all right folks let's react with excitement as we dive into the solution of scientific innovation chemistry [Music] breathe in some O2 as we spark up for one of our Noble winners who's got that gas the side of the prize for advancements in medicine goes to cannabis now okay so unfortunately Japan but in their honor uh we will tell them about it soon so that brings us to next uh it's time [51:32] to invest your attention as we capitalize on the extraordinary progress in the field of Economics we're here to credit the Brilliant Minds who have been balancing the quotes of our understanding uh they've been mining crypto economic Solutions decrypting coordination problems and truly ledgering the way in economics of the digital era the side Enterprise for advancements in economics goes to the mechanism Institute foreign [Applause] looking at every single crypto economic [52:13] incentive out there and making it publicly open source you can find them at mechanism.institute and you can find Cannabis style uh I don't remember their website but I will post it on our Twitter thank you folks Let's uh prepare to count your excitement as we add up to the Pinnacle of numerical Innovation mathematics our winner is a true champion of hidden figures mastering private multi-sig with hidden owners making them the some Heroes of our time deciding for us for advancements in mathematics goes to Enrique Shields [52:54] is very interesting that you have this new thing where you can trade assets and be protected while you're doing it and they're really doing some interesting stuff in math and ZK nice next up next up let's turn the page into the realm of literature and scientific publishing our winner pen down knowledge insights and turn complex Concepts into paperback wisdom get ready to cover them with Applause deciders prize for advancements in literature and scientific publishing goes to research hub [Applause] um Justin we have Patrick back [53:36] wards is it still there Patrick are you still there did we lose you Patrick yeah all right all right well research mode lastly lastly Hold Your Fire as we cease hostilities to celebrate advancements in the Realms of peace put down the Peace Pipe and put up your two thingies as we award the final side to Enterprise tonight um yes through their click and mortar efforts our winner has been upload uploading [54:24] Harmony building a governance later for the worldwide peace the award goes to Medico [Applause] and they have a very cool website where they've documented it all publicly so I'd encourage everyone to check that out too yep so now let's get the winners back up here upstage and Stage a little photo Optimus [Applause] Andrew Andrew back a little we got a quick picture bring the cups yeah everyone everyone cheers [55:16] one two three one more two more nice yeah perfect yay [Music] okay all right well thank you guys for coming out tonight and if you have any questions um make sure to check out our website um dsi.nyc make sure to come to the next event and continue to chat with each other and mingle and we'll close it up in like 15-20 minutes but thank you all for coming out and around for class for the first hour [55:58] foreign [Applause] [56:10] [Music] [57:05] foreign [57:29] [Music] thank you thank you so much of life yeah yeah yeah I'm back but I'm back yeah um