DeSciNYC

DeSciNYC

← Back to videos

Talk & transcript

What Are We Breathing on the NYC Subway?

Jack Klein

Transcript

Download text

Automatically generated transcript, lightly edited for names, scientific terms, and obvious transcription errors. Some errors may remain. Select a timestamp to watch that moment on YouTube.

0:03

Thank you guys for coming. I appreciate everyone coming out tonight. It's a little hot and sweaty. But I need to have everybody here. We do have an AI t-shirt on. Oh, okay. Well, some people like it. Some people don't. I wrote a book called Regulating AI, so this is the counter hedge. Some people thought that was funny. And we have this cool thing. So you can be very professional. Okay, so my name is Michael. I host the DeSciNYC things. I gave a talk. Thank you all for coming to the talk on subway quality, air quality in the subway. Before we start, how many people have cared decently about the air quality in the subway? So what sparked this is I bought all these sensors, and I started doing all these...

1:05

Little readings. This one measures, like, we have C's. This one measures random things. Noise. You can measure noise. You can measure radon. You can measure, oh my god, oh, this will be fun. We can measure CO2 throughout the night. The air quality in the subway now is probably way worse in here. So currently it's 1222. So we can... We can just put it here and we'll see how it goes throughout the night. It's like water to paint. If you feel your cognitive decline. We have AC in here. Okay, so I gave a talk last, who was here last time on the talk on prediction markets? That was like two weeks ago. We're starting to decide. Oh, and by the way, if anyone wants to help out with the DeSci, it's only me basically running this, so.

2:06

We're always looking for more people to help out with operations or recruiting speakers or advertising. So if you're interested in that, just come up to me after. And I would love to work together with people. Okay, so we gave an update on the prediction market stuff. How many people are interested in prediction markets? Cool. So the problem that prediction markets have, I'm just going to give a two-minute talk just for an update, is that people want to know, do drugs work for people?

2:36

And there's no fast way to do this right now. It's only just like, you have to do a clinical trial which takes tens of years and hundreds of millions of dollars. And there's no incentive for people to aggregate data together. So the idea here is that if you could use prediction markets to allow people to speculate on if a drug is going to work, this would accelerate science. And you would have to, you can speculate on elections, you can speculate on sports, you can speculate on companies.

3:04

But no one has really used markets to allow people to forecast if science would work. And science is so much more powerful and useful to society than if someone's going to win a sports or if someone's going to win an election. So we had the idea to create a prediction market around clinical trials. And so we did this and we have people speculating currently on phase one, phase two, and phase three outcomes.

3:34

So phase one, phase two, phase three outcomes. And this one's on different types of drugs. And there's an intense market out there of people who are doing experimentation on themselves, but also people who are building AI models to see which types of drugs are working. Then we also benchmark different AI agents on this. So we have all the frontier models and open weights betting on which ones. And Claude is crushing it right now.

4:04

It's doing a much better job than other ones. And, you know, we have different types of people betting. We have biotech people and we have payers and insurers taking different sides of this bet. And the reason I mention all of this is because we also have an app that you guys can download to allow you to get your own data. So right now there's a lot of AIs that are bashing each other to death trying to speculate if clinical trial is going to happen in one way. But what's like...

4:33

What's an alpha that actually makes a difference is like allowing people to contribute their N of 1 data from their health kit on their phone. So on examples being we're running these shadow trials on how Reddit impacts people's sleep, on psychedelics and depression, on skincare stuff. And this is a way to sort of monetize your data, which is very cool. So you can download the app. We're hiring. So I started this company. We raised some money.

5:01

If you're interested in applying for a job in data, in partnerships, in social media, anything, it's a small but mighty team. The team is about three people now, and if you're looking for a job where we'd love to chat, you can go there, or come up and talk with me after. If you're a biotech person, or if you work for a biotech hedge fund and you'd be interested in using this product, send me a DM on Twitter at Endpoint Arena.

5:30

And then lastly, we're having a talk next week on peptides. So everyone's asking about peptides. So Julius is an amazing guy. He runs the California Peptide Club. And he'll be talking next week on peptides and everything he wants to know but we're afraid to ask around peptides. Does anyone have any questions before we jump in? Three, two, one. Forever hold your peace. Okay, so come up and talk to me if you're interested in Endpoint Arena after. But I met Jack through DeSciNYC. And Jack is very, very famous for all the work that he's done on TikTok. Jack fan club here. And Jack, I actually first saw Jack because I saw him on TikTok complaining about the MTA and how terrible it was.

6:24

And that resonated with me. And so without further ado, we'd like to hand the stage over to Jack. Before I come on, I'm going to let Emily Sun break up. She runs a sub stack called Feed Me. And she did an article. We did an interview last summer about Subway Heat. And she was coming tonight. So I asked her to kind of just lead me in a bit. So welcome Emily to the stage. Hi, everyone.

7:04

Jack asked me to do this about 48 hours ago, so I put together something quickly, but as he said, I'm a writer in New York. I write a newsletter on sub-staff called Teed Me, and I cover businesses and people in New York and sort of how those all affect New York's culture. Over the years, it's also become a place, whether in the comment section or my chats, to talk about...

7:31

Bigger issues or problems or questions that my audience has and kind of discuss them. So Jack and I met from the internet and one of the first things that drew me to him were all those little gadgets that Michael showed you before. I think some of your gadgets might overlap. There's the AirBeam monitor and the Kestrel thermometer and I think that not enough people have a signature gadget or a secret weapon.

7:59

And those who do are quite magnetic to me. When I interviewed Jack for my newsletter, he taught me about heat and its effect on train stations. And since then, I haven't walked through a housing project in Red Hook or up a broken escalator in the subway the same way. He was also a perfect case study of how to harness the power of a growing online audience for good. I'm going to read a small part of the introduction to our conversation that I published last August.

8:27

It's refreshing to speak to someone who is building an online presence with a mission to educate and change. After speaking with Jack, it sounds like it might even be possible through the presentation of data. I also just think collecting data about something other than ourselves is cool, and more of us should be curious about how soil pH affects hydrangea colors or the correlation between font choices and book sales.

8:55

Jack really cares about small interventions that can make a difference in the quality of life for the average New Yorker. This isn't a fantasy or something that you see on a poster in a classroom. These things can actually be done. As some of you might know, in Zoran's first few weeks of being elected, we saw him fix that annoying little bump when you come off the bridge from Williamsburg into Manhattan on the Williamsburg Bridge.

9:19

And while reading about the heat wave last week, I also learned that he's committed to planting more trees in the city. I didn't know that that was something that his team was working on. And I think, you know, it's like one of the first things that we learned in school is like how to plant a tree. And then we kind of like don't revisit that idea. And these changes might seem small, but they can make life in a city that is already very hard for many of us a little bit easier.

9:48

And they can also make people happier. And I think that people become better neighbors and friends and parents when they're even just a little bit happier. The city is in an exciting moment for people who care about quality of life and for those who are optimistic that people can make a difference. And Jack is a cool guy, but he's... Also, part of a broader movement to make the city a more livable place, even if that action is as small as handing out water in a subway station, which he did last week during that crazy heat wave. The other night when I came home to my apartment, my air conditioning wasn't working well. I was traveling for a few days and it was really hot. And I actually DMed Jack when this was happening. And I was like, wow, there are people in the city that need air conditioners. And after just like a few minutes of research, I realized that.

10:39

People don't really need air conditioners. They need their electric bills paid. And there's a really easy way on your Con Edison bill to just check off donating a few dollars every month and Con Edison will match it, which is cool. I'm also open to more ideas on that front because it doesn't seem like New York is going to get cooler. It seems like our summers are going to continue to get hotter. So it's important to come together in rooms like this and discuss these things and come up with possible solutions.

11:05

Several people in New York have died from the heat in New York. Several people in New York have died from the heat this summer and that number is even higher in neighboring states like New Jersey. Yes, Jack's videos are entertaining and I think that NBC should consider giving him like a little weekend Bill Nye segment on the local news. But the fact that you're all here tonight means that he's also engaged a group of people who want to figure out solutions to a subway system that 3 million, maybe more, use a day. I'm excited to hear him speak tonight, and hopefully we leave with some actionable ideas of how to make the city an easier and healthier place to live. Let me set my laptop real quick. We can get a picture. All right, everyone. Three, two, one. Smile. Say cheese. Say DeSci.

12:33

And then we'll do a panorama. What? Does anyone, actually, I'm curious, is anyone from the MTA here? Oh. Oh, okay. So if you want to chat, chat with Xavier. Xavier, you work at the MTA? You work at the MTA? Oh, did you reach out? Oh. Oh, okay, never mind. Does anyone here work for the MTA? Oh, you do? Okay. So if people want to chat and actually close the loop, you should go chat with him.

13:07

Not all at once. Do you know Subway Builders? Do you know Subway Builders? Like the game? You know. Okay. A lot of people do. And it's like a game where you build the subway. But I know the guy that runs it. I'm having a hard time. Hold on. He's working the board. Does it look? Can you see the projector? Oh, sorry. Does it work? Just monitor if they change it. Can you see both the camera screens? Can you see both the camera screens? Okay, I'm ready. Thank you again for coming. Thank you for speaking beforehand. I'm going to sit down.

14:34

Okay, my name is Jack. I run like a fictional lab called New York Lab, where we're trying to reimagine public spaces sort of by bringing whimsy to transport, but also very really trying to improve the quality of life for commuters. Before I start, I just want to thank my sponsor. Oh, this didn't work. Hold on. Hold on, hold on, hold on. Let me try this. Anyways, I'll just go. Yeah.

15:31

Okay, yeah, something my sponsor, GenSpark AI. Slides in 10 minutes, not 10 p.m. I actually just fed this ad. My email was like 15 minutes ago and made these slides, so I hope it works out. Before we start, I just want to talk about a 1998 project called Parasite by Michael Rakowitz. He created these. Inexpensive plastic structures that he connected to the heat exhaust of HVAC systems and kind of gave a place for people around the street to sleep in, in like a warm kind of encapsulation of like, you know, a small little structure. And I think about this project a lot in terms of like, he wasn't really trying to propose a solution to this systemic problem, but more so just trying to get people to think about the spaces that we live in.

16:28

And things that we might take for advantage. And thinking outside the box in terms of, okay, there's all this heat coming out of this building. How to actually maybe harness it rather than just let it go into the air. So this has informed a lot of my work. Dare I say work? I don't know. And so I'm just going to talk a bit about previous stuff that I've done before getting to the heat project. Just a couple of things that I'm working on the subway.

16:55

Like two years ago, there's this broken display that I would pass, I think on the 6L station. For like months, it never got fixed. And then I put up like a museum placard on a broken display, tape and plastic on metal. I don't know. It felt fun. I was living in Ridgewood, Queens like two years ago, and I put up, I don't know why I did this, but I basically put up like a blank piece of paper and take markers to a wall that was like near my house.

17:25

I said, how are you feeling today? And I was just curious if people would interact with it. I'd basically put it up on the wall, leave for a day, and then come back and just see if people either took it down or if they wrote stuff on it or graffitied it or tore it apart. And I like this one. It says, I'm recovering from the NDMA. But I would put these on the Williamsburg Bridge. It got torn down. I would put it other places. I think oftentimes we think that putting things in public will just get immediately.

17:55

You know messed with, but that's not always the case. I was pointing like digital thermometer guns at trash bags in Chinatown during the heat wave like two years ago to see how hot it would get. This guy said, I think the trash is animal parts mixed with mung bean. Like a couple months ago I made this sticker called No Phone Zone. I've been getting really into like all the screens in the subways and how none of us are asking for...

18:25

These screens and the digital ads and how we have no agency in these decisions that are being made. But I think it's actually really bad for us and even the ambient light entering my eyes. 6.30am going to work feels very bad. So I made this fake news posting and put it on Instagram and all my friends were saying, Jack, congrats. You actually got a job with the city and the MTA. So I think I messed up the satire part. But...

18:55

Still just thinking about how we can, you know, think differently about how we're operating through these spaces. Recently, I made a gallery frame with some kind of misted plastic on it that I would put over the Digital Subway ads. I was measuring it. I went to some gallery, you know, like frame gallery in the West Village to make this way too expensive frame. And put it over the ads just as another exploration around.

19:26

You know, I don't want to see these screens in the subway. Can we do anything about it? Do we actually have a say in it as the customers of the train station? Or is it really out front in MTA who get to decide these things? I also made these goggles. As a way to not switch screens. I made this video with my friend Andrea a couple of weeks ago. Obviously not practical really, but again, it's just really like...

19:55

I don't know, just poking fun at the stuff and thinking differently about, you know, the public spaces I've been through. I was reading a book on the train and was walking through Williamsburg with these goggles on. Let's see. Okay, so that was sort of, you know, some stuff that I've done before, but the genesis of this project, I guess, is why I'm here today is I moved here in March 2024, so relatively recent.

20:22

And I was living in Ridgewood, Queens, and I was commuting to Hell's Kitchen for work. My friend got me a production job at this crazy content studio. And that was my first summer in the station, in New York. And I was really fascinated by how hot it was getting in the subway stations. And one day I just had an idea to get one of these digital thermometer guns and start pointing at the surfaces in 14th Street, New York Square, which was my transfer station. And film a TikTok, which makes me sometimes.

20:52

I want to puke to even say that. But I made a couple videos in 2024 and they gained a lot of traction among people living in New York. And everyone was like, you know, go to my station, 34th Street, Herald Square, go to 181st One Station, Elevator, it's the hottest place we've ever been. I realized that people have a very visceral connection with their station. We all have our station that we go through. And it made me think that we have...

21:19

This is an issue that everyone knows about. Millions of people every day are experiencing it. But it seems underreported on. And also, the solutions seem doing great. Everyone's saying that, you know, MTA is just, where's the money going? And it seems very kind of pessimistic. So, there's some of the comments that I would get online around, like, yeah, MTA getting billions in eight packages every year. Money always goes poof. Or, you know, maybe figure out how to ventilate. Or, you know, look out for the elderly and young children.

21:48

Also around, I thought this was really interesting, like, being on SSRIs during the summers, especially Dangerous and Miserable. Or, how some of that they were going to pass out, who's so on Canal Street. So, that was the summer of 2024, I just made a couple of those videos. But it really got me thinking, you know, I've done these projects before, like, in public space, and I'm just generally curious about how people move through the city. So, it's this thing where, like...

22:18

It's hot now. We had a heatwave last week. But then it gets cold again in the fall and we sort of forget about it. But it's ultimately going to come back again even hotter every summer. And it seems like we kind of just forget about it. And it comes back and we're like, what are we going to do? And everyone forgets about it. Whereas I find it really interesting with other natural disasters like flooding or hurricanes or other things that leaves visible residue. With the flooding, we can see the grates. There's leaves over it. We can see the flooded streets. There's water in the stations.

22:46

So we are constantly reminded of it. With the heat in the summer, we forget about it. So I was thinking about how to take advantage of this issue that everyone experiences. I put the dates on here. November of 2024. I remember I texted my friend Will. I went back into computer science and I was curious if it was like... Possible to install sensors in stations and start to actually track heat and humidity data because the MTA doesn't actually, well, I've learned more now, but it doesn't seem like they actually have any data around how hot it is or what they're trying to do about it. So it's like, okay, well, if they're not doing it, is there anything we can do? And also in New York, it seems like you can do whatever you want in terms of art. You can put stuff in stations and no one's going to say anything or you can put a placard on a broken display. No one really cares. So it's kind of right for...

23:45

Artistic experimentation. And around the same time as that, when I was asking my friend Will if I could hack into a thermometer and somehow start to stream data. This was in February of 2025. So it says that New York City's subway is using Google Pixels to listen for trap defects. And I thought this was really interesting. So New York City and the MTA partnered with Google Public Sector. So Google Public Sector is...

24:12

A branch of Google that uses their private funds to push public projects. And I guess currently what happens, there's specific engineers at the MTA who ride through the trains and listen for defects. I guess you can tell by what it sounds like. And through just listening, they can tell what parts of the tracks need repaired. And what Google did is they just had a bunch of cheap phones with a lav mic within the train and started collecting as much audio data as possible.

24:40

And then train some type of model where they could programmatically tell what parts of the system needed fixed. So that was an example of using relatively inexpensive technology and partnering with the city to solve a problem that ultimately before was someone just going around and doing it themselves. Data collection device. This is in February of 2025. Here, this is a Xiaomi thermometer for like $3 that I got off Alibaba or something. This is an Arduino port, which is like a microcomputer that you can, you know, put simple like C++ code into. And this is a portable battery. And really, you're able to crack these thermometers and put certain code in them that will make it stream its data to the computer. And then you can make the computer like...

25:37

Stream the temperature data to, you know, a database and start to collect long-term data. It looked like a bomb. And basically for, like, again, I made those videos in 2024, the summer of 2024. From then until, like, the next one, basically, it's, like, downtime. So I was thinking, I was, like, in the station so much, doing research with this thing. This is, like, a photo someone took of me. I was, like, in 14 Street Bean Square a lot, like, in 2025.

26:07

I was getting all this shit over my hands, but I was putting that thing in the rafters of the station, trying to figure out where it could be seen, but also where it could still connect to internet. There's a SIM card attached to this as well, so it doesn't connect to Wi-Fi, it actually is using data to stream the data. And it didn't really work. There's a lot of Bluetooth interference in the train stations with all the metal poles and all the different devices down there that we don't really see. The advertising digital screens use a bunch of technology too. It's the point where I would test it out in my room and it would stream the data perfectly. But then when I would put it out in the train station, it wouldn't work at all. So I was carrying my laptop into 14 Street Community Square every week, trying to debug it there. And it just...

27:04

Was really cumbersome and started to not be fun. So what I ended up doing, I found these Kestrel drop, like basically temperature loggers that would store the data on board. So it just seemed easier. It was kind of a built-in solution. I wouldn't have to actually develop it myself. So I bought like 10 of these and I put tape over them. So this is in June now of 2025. That previous picture was in February. Put tape over them.

27:33

And I put magnets on the back of them because all those metal rafters in the stations are metal so they're obviously magnetic. And what I did then was I hid them within the rafters of like 10 or so high traffic stations in Manhattan. And it was actually a map. So I put one in Broadway Lafayette. I put two in 14th Sydney Square. I put one in 34th Street Road Square.

28:00

Put one in Hudson Yards. Put one in Times Square. I put one in 168 One Station and then I put one in the elevator in the 181st One Station. Like behind the security camera. The MTA puts out kind of foot traffic reports. So some of these were largely based on what are the highest foot traffic stations in the system and then some like these two up here in Washington Heights were more Anecdotal data of people telling me online, like, you gotta visit these stations. And, you know, what I'm thinking about, this whole time I've been thinking about it is, why are we doing this? And like, when I was putting it here, I was trying to be sort of intentional about how I was putting them or where I was putting them. The goal is to try to get the best representation of what it feels like for a commuter to stand next to the subway platform waiting for the train. So I was like, can I get it like three to eight feet off the ground?

28:56

Facing the platform. So I'm sure as you all know, when the train pulls on the platform in the summer, the exhaust from the ACs blows onto your face. That's a large reason why it's so hot in the stations in the summer. That and the friction from the brakes. So I was trying to be very intentional at where I was placing them. This is a lot of the quote-unquote research that I was doing last summer. And this is what the data looked like. So I was recording...

29:25

A data point every five minutes at all these stations, and it was recording temperature, humidity, and heat index. And heat index is the feels like temperature. It's like some type of calculation of heat and humidity, right? Because it can be 90 degrees out, but it's also, you know, subtropical environment in New York and in the station, so it's not actually representing what it feels like. So I wanted to get that, like, it was all about what does it feel like for a commuter actually to be in the station. And again, to go back to those comments that I...

29:55

Put on the screen before, me as an able-bodied person, I can withstand these temperatures. I've been in the stations a lot, but for a lot of populations, like pregnant people, the elderly, people with certain disabilities, people on SSRIs, et cetera, et cetera, this is actually a public health issue. And also the police in the stations who are there eight hours a day, the people who work construction in the tunnels, the MTA people who work in the booths.

30:25

Like, that's actually, they're down there the most. So, those are the types of populations that I'm trying to, like, advocate for with this research, not so much just, I mean, also the everyday person, but, um, and with this data, it wasn't streaming, like, I wasn't able to, like, send it to a database, so what I was doing last summer was going to all these stations every week and downloading it via Bluetooth, so I was, like, walking on my phone, and I, like, always forgot where they were, because it was, like, in some obscure rafter, and I was, like, had to be within 100 feet of the device.

30:54

So like seven stations a week. In Washington Heights, it was like all of Manhattan. Doing that weekly. Basically through June, July, August, September, and October. So I have like five months or so of data. Like tens of thousands of rows of data because it was every five minutes. And at the same time last summer I was continuing to make kind of silly videos around like just walking around with like a temperature logger, showing people how hot it gets.

31:25

I have a sauna hat. I was doing like, there's a local company called, it's like an AirBeam. So I was doing like air quality stuff. Also, sorry, I'm not going to talk about air quality at all. That was on the event description. And I was also like, in elevators, this is the elevator, 181 station. It feels like 104 degrees. And this is below a hospital. So, you know, to even get in the station too, you have to take the elevator. There's no stairs. So I was like, just trying to like.

31:53

It's like a dual-sided project. There's like the data collection part of it. And there's also the videos and trying to like raise awareness through the great internet. And this kind of raised, I got some press last summer through these videos. The New York Post called it a quirky art project. I did some of the Fox 5 News with the Weather Channel where we're just basically going down and I was just talking about this stuff. It felt insane, but it felt worthwhile. I did interviews with Columbia Climate School around interviewing me around the data that I had. With Emily, she kind of coined this term, the lab, under the subway. It felt good because for a while this was...

32:46

Like a very niche, I mean still is niche, but kind of a passion project where I was sort of nervous to talk to people about it because it feels just like insane to like, the whole thing just felt wild, but, and like kind of embarrassing to talk about, but once I started getting more people who were actually working within the environmental journalism industries talking about it, it kind of validated a bit and made me feel more comfortable, you know, trying to find people to work on it with me. So at the same time, last summer I...

33:14

Was doing like crazy outreach to people and like trying to build. There's the social media part but the goal isn't to like gain Instagram followers. The goal is to find solutions for these problems. However naive that may be. Because maybe it's actually impossible. But for example like I started to talk to like scientists and researchers and industry people like a lot. Last summer all throughout kind of 2024. For example Jeff Freeman was an atmospheric researcher at UAlbany. Nate Hupman is like a.

33:45

Getting a master's data science at Johns Hopkins. James works in private equity. Joel works for a sensor company. Peter owns an air quality device company. Aurora works for the mayor's office. Billy was an architect at Dattner. Jacko worked at another sensor company. Dr. Neruzi is a professor of architecture at CUNYCity Tech. And so we were trying to figure out, like, okay, how can we actually use this data to push for solutions? And I actually don't know anything about the science of it, so it's nice to have people on board that actually kind of understood how these systems work. So, especially James, he has a background in private equity and, like, got a business degree at Stanford. Love the man, but he was going insane. He was sending, like, last July, like, we were just sending, like...

34:44

Shit tons of emails. So it was really funny. So it was from JP Morgan. We were sending emails to people like JP Morgan. He was like, I reached out from New York Lab where we've built a new environmental intelligent platform focused on quantifying overlooked urban economic risks, starting with extreme heat exposure costs. It's hard to even read. New York City's underground transit infrastructure. We've developed a heat excess index, a standardized metric that captures the delta between underground and surface level heat conditions using live sensor data and calibrated historical baselines.

35:13

As ESG frameworks increase into measurable location specific physical risk metrics, we believe that HEI can complement your team's working. You get the point. We were kind of bullshitting. There was none of this stuff. But he kept sending emails to people. To Jano Lieber, the president of the MTA, we're reaching out on behalf of a data-first environmental intelligence initiative focused on quantifying urban climate risks. Reached out to Governor Hochul.

35:42

Reached out to people that work at the Health Department for New York. All kind of saying the same thing. Who else? To Citi, like to banks and insurance. I'm still Polish. I still think this is true, like that this data can be used for making informed decisions around how we should be thinking about infrastructure in the future. Especially because this data doesn't really exist. Besides this data set and a couple others. And another interesting one that I thought was the Wall Street Journal.

36:13

This one I thought was really interesting. Because James and I were thinking about, okay, we want to push for solutions and ultimately work with the MTA and the city and the state. But also, I'm doing this for free and I want to find a way to make money off this ethically with the data set. So something I think is really interesting, I still think is true, is really reaching out to people that work at Lyft and Uber and Waymo, etc. With the idea that, for example, there's a lot of data points that go into their...

36:40

Pricing algorithms, right? If it's raining outside, you're probably going to cost more to get an Uber. So we're thinking like, if it's hotter under, this sounds insane too, but if it's hotter underground, you might be more incentivized to take a rideshare and could actually start to incorporate our dataset into their pricing algorithms. We never got any responses, so I don't know what that's all about. With them at least. So I'm going to now just talk about a couple.

37:09

Of the people we did talk to, kind of, 2025 summer and going into this year. So, and I'm going to start throwing screenshots of just pitch decks. So, James cold LinkedIn message, the CEO of the Weather Company, which is a private equity-backed company that is the parent company of the Weather Channel, which is the number one weather app on the App Store. And with them, we were really curious if they would be interested in using this data so they could surface these insights as another widget on their app, showing how hot it would be underground. Again, as a way for people who are more vulnerable to these types of conditions, so they could actually see how hot it would be underground. Would these things be useful? I don't really know, but we were sort of betting on that. They didn't really see the vision.

38:03

It was confusing and then someone from their partnerships dated, and I'm going to start showing emails, someone from their partnerships team was like, Jack, it was a pleasure speaking with you last week. It's a very compelling idea, but it would be important to confirm that any data we ingest is done so with the appropriate permissions from the state, metro authorities, or other relevant entities. And obviously this is all, I was disinstalling sensors by myself, so it wasn't. And I left her on the email. I didn't respond, I got nervous.

38:30

And another thing I wanted the weather company to do, because they have a lot of money obviously, I was like, we need someone to help us lobby on our behalf to the MTA to help us get us permits to install more sensors and to be able to legally do this. Because to actually be able to do this and maybe sell the data or use the data for weather tech, we need permission from the MTA. And this was quite naive of me because MTA is controlled by the state.

38:59

The governor, the state legislators, and I think we were approaching this not in a right way exactly, but other people that we talked to. This is another pitch deck. This is kind of an intro slide. I got in contact with the team who did that original, from Google Public Sector, who did the original other project with the MTA and pitched them on that idea. Told them what I was doing, they were interested in talking. And I also talked to the MTA.

39:27

Obviously similar, it was the exact same intro slides from the pitch deck, but it was basically cleaner, cooler subway stations for all new workers. I'll just show you a couple slides from that pitch deck, showing them the problem. So the problem, subway stations can reach 120 degrees Fahrenheit and heat index, which is the fuel's like. Obviously this impacts riders and workers' health, especially those vulnerable. Lack of data, so heat is measured only anecdotally.

39:56

Forward one-off studies in subway stations. And then why is this a priority? The MTI releases a climate resiliency roadmap. They're largely focused on flooding because in 2012 or 2013, Superstorm Sandy did like $5 billion of damages to the subway system due to flooding. So they're really concerned about that. But goals 8, 9, and 10 are about heat. And goal 8 is about expanding underground air circulation and cooling within the subway system. So that's...

40:26

Alternative problem and this is another part of the pitch deck which is why the design looks different. Basically, this is what I was pitching to Google Public Sector and the MTA was that we need to deploy more sensors in the stations for longer periods of time because right now I only have like seven stations and it was kind of very crude data. Also, this is what I'm very on right now is I want to explore near-term solutions like seeding. They're taking seeding out of stations.

40:56

The most popular stations like 14th Street Union Square, there's like six places to sit. And they're actively taking away benches, they're putting the leaning benches up too. It's like, this seems so wrong, right? Think about even the more vulnerable people, like people with disabilities, there's nowhere to sit. You can be in the station for upwards of 20 minutes. So, you know, seating, places to drink water, or like ventilation fans to reduce heat stress. We've all been under the fans in the stations and it seems like we're just getting like hot air blown onto us.

41:25

It's like who designed these fans and what's their name and can I talk to them? And then also I was thinking about like longer term solutions like geothermal cooling, capturing the heat in the stations and selling it as a utility, etc. So I hope this is making sense. You can say something that doesn't. But so those are like the three very large leads that I had last summer and like going into the winter of 2025 was.

41:55

The Weather Company, which didn't really work. And then Google Public Sector I was really hyped on. And then the MTA, of course, that's the nexus of this all. So I gave that pitch to MTA, like, November of 2025. And then there was like a back and forth. There's so many follow-up emails always. But April 1st, 2026, I finally got a message from the head of the climate resiliency team saying that we don't have the bandwidth to collaborate at this time.

42:24

I was literally offering them to give them my data for free. I didn't even really- or like to just let me install more sensors in the stations. Like I wasn't asking for money really. And they just didn't have the bandwidth, which is fine. And then Google Public Sector hit me with, I think we are passing here, my friend. And I don't want to talk too much about them because I actually just- this was like a year ago and I actually just LinkedIn messaged them.

42:49

Woman who's like the transportation head of Google Publix. I was like, hey, swing back around. You guys want to explore this again? She said, yeah, we would love to. And like some of the people that were on the team have left since then, including this guy. So, maybe people just can come around. And they can give me a job at Google. Other things like we talked to the city council member of Washington Heights, De La Rosa. We talked to her like way last year in 2025.

43:19

February of 2026. Saying that they're short-staffed and like don't have time to talk really. So it's all these like kind of follow-up messages and it feels like we're like trying really hard to outreach the people but it was always the wrong people I guess or the wrong kind of the methods. Okay this is where I wish I had my notes but um actually I might just switch over really quick. No. Okay anyways you'll get the point. Anyways so

44:03

On top of all of those conversations, in September of 2025, the NTA released a request for information, so an RFI for geothermal cooling technologies for two stations in Washington Heights, 168th Street and 181st Street, were actually the stations that I had sensors in. And they've done this before, they did this in 2023, but they just wanted, they were soliciting information, it wasn't like a guaranteed contract, they just wanted people to send them kind of a feasibility analysis, like what would be the possibility.

44:31

To actually capture the heat within the stations and then sell it as a utility to above ground like you think in Washington Heights there's Columbia and there's New York Presbyterian. So that was kind of their goal, like how can we make money off this? It's always about money. And I'm going to go to my notes really quick because it might just be a blank screen but I'm just going to read you some of the stuff that just to make this sort of sciencey. So.

44:58

I teamed up with that whole team on that Google Meet that I kind of introduced. I also found a geothermal engineering company based out of Florida called HECGEO and convinced them to help us submit this RFI. And we submitted like a detailed 10-page RFI. Where here's sort of what we said was kind of the intro to is that our team frames the RFI through a data-first methodology.

45:23

Before designing or drilling geothermal systems, the NTA requires reliable, continuous temperature and humidity data to inform decision-making. To that end, we propose a pilot program that couples environmental monitoring with feasibility analysis, creating a reputable foundation for future cooling interventions. And then there's 15 feasibility questions that EggGeo did all of it. I don't have any information on this, but I'm just going to read a couple just so you can get an idea of what it was.

45:49

So, some of the stuff that MTA was curious about is what is the potential magnitude of thermal resource capacity across the MTA network? And NGEO said that the magnitude is enormous, likely measured in tens of thousands of tons of cooling capacity, but a true number requires a deep analysis of all 281 underground stations. They're also curious which assets have the greatest potential and how can they be used. The 23 existing deep wells...

46:15

The MT already has all these deep wells that are filled with cool water. It says the RFI notes they pump 60 to 66 degree Fahrenheit water 24-7. This is a perfect source for an open loop geothermal system. The pump rooms are a secondary asset and the fan plants are for air distribution, not a source. And then the last one that I'll read is what innovative thermo models in dollar value?

46:41

And, like Geo said, the most innovative model is waste heat recovery. Instead of just cooling the station, you can capture that heat and sell it to an external off-taker, like a nearby hospital or university, as the RFI knows that is being explored at 168th Street. And, basically, like Geo said, based on internal scoping, we estimate that completing this next phase with the rigor required for actual results would require approximately 394 professional hours of engineering analysis.

47:07

This effort would include detailed subsurface modeling, load simulations, cost-benefit analysis, and system integration planning. The outcome would be a fully engineered feasibility report ready to inform pilot design and potential funding opportunities. So we did that and then we didn't get a response and it's been like eight months so... And then I've largely fallen off with these people, all the scientists and researchers I was working with. It's just kind of getting burnt out around...

47:32

Reaching out to the people that we think are the decision makers and then ultimately they're not wanting to listen to us, you know, these kind of academics from the outside. All the while that this was happening, you know, we're raising bus fares and train fares to three dollars. There was a bunch of power outages last summer. It's very hot. There's flooding constantly. It feels doomed. And I think that's why I'm really interested in this domain is because it's such like a culturally relevant system. The subway, we all take it.

48:02

And there's so much shit happening, and it's like this web of not only so much stuff is happening, it's all very culturally relevant, right? Like everyone experiences it, and that kind of inspires me to continue swallowing it, I suppose. I have more better words on the notes, which I don't have right now. But, and then at the same time, I'm always fascinated by these comments that people are making on these videos, these silly videos I make. One, on the right.

48:29

Nothing will ever be done about it. Started in 1904 and has never been addressed. The year 2025 will not be changed. NYC is 472 stations and it would be incredibly expensive to fix the issue. And on the left. So tired of these damn transplants, I grew up with NWCC on the actual train. How can you even get a phone signal at one point? Pull your skirt down. So it's kind of, this is also what I'm really fascinated by. It's like, one, I grew up here, I'm from here. I'm not, like, this is what people are like, I'm from here.

48:58

And it's always been like this. And there's no world in which it can be different. That's like one thing. And then also is, it used to be worse, right? We used to put the windows down on the train so they actually just put up with it, right? We experienced worse. And I see my kind of, where I feel like I can contribute is getting people to think outside the box and a bit more creatively about things. Or I'm posting random videos online.

49:26

Asking like why can't we have plants in stations? That's what I'm exploring right now a lot. It's like putting plants in stations like more fans. Like why are the fans on the ceilings if the hot air is on the ceiling? Shouldn't they be like to the side? Like I don't really have the answers but like who made these decisions and are they arbitrarily? Is it because the outlet's on the ceiling or is it because that's actually the best place to put it? Or should we actually put it over here? And like people get really mad about these simple questions like getting asked that because it's like challenging their idea of like what it means to be a New Yorker.

49:55

And I think it actually takes someone who's not from here, like myself, to come and be like, actually this is really fucked up. And I can think of ten ways that are maybe impossible, but ten ways that we can actually fix stuff. And it maybe just takes a bit of creative thinking and kind of an artistic aspect. Someone else on the NYC Post said, yes, it's called summertime, it happens every single year. So it's just again, there's different camps. Okay, so...

50:29

It all feels doomed. And I tried collaborating with the MTA and the city and nothing has worked yet. I know it takes time. But then I'm also reading about people in different cities doing things by themselves and subverting the normal processes to get what they want. So for example, this was an article. Residents in Iowa were fed up with unsafe streets. They actually started painting their own crosswalks.

51:00

And doing it themselves. Also in LA, there's some neighborhoods that are really kind of choked by air quality and the city isn't doing anything to monitor it so they're buying their own air quality monitors and they're putting it themselves. And to what degree collecting the data can help, I still don't really understand because I collected a lot of data and it seems to not have done a whole lot. But I'm inspired by these people.

51:29

In cities who are kind of taking into their own hands. I think in New York there's a large opportunity to do this because you can literally do whatever you want and no one cares. Like I installed like a thermometer with like a bomb in the station like no one said anything and I got away with it all. So I am confident that this is also possible in New York if not more. So how am I incorporating? How am I thinking about this? I'm almost done. Just this past weekend my friend Darian, Luke and I we went.

51:58

Into 14th Street Union Square with... I bought a water dispenser off Amazon, like the one you would see in an office. And I bought some five-gallon jugs from Home Depot. And then Luke brought his portable generator to cool the water. And we brought it into the station during the heat wave where it felt like 110 degrees. And we just sort of see how people interact with it, right? This is a guy giving his kids some water. This is a guy chugging some water. Luke gave a cup of water to a train conductor.

52:28

She seemed really hard to let it out. I'm gonna go back to my notes. It's a little dark. So in that, we did that. In two hours, 66 people used the water station. One tourist asked me, don't you have anything better to do with your time? Interestingly enough, we actually had to ask people, a lot of the people had to be asked, like, do you want water? Because we were doing, like, we ran multiple experiments.

52:54

We were either standing off to the side and seeing people interact with it, and then we also went and gave people the cups of water. We noticed that people were more often willing to take the water when there was someone there giving to them. Because I don't think we're used to seeing, obviously we're not used to seeing this in public space, so I think there's like sanitary concerns possibly. We're just seeing things within the transition that I'm not used to seeing, and I don't know if I would even interact with it. And go back to my notes.

53:24

Yeah, we also like paper cups and like people were grabbing and stuff so I don't know how sanitary that is. But I think it was a really interesting experience. This is the first time in two years through this heat research that I've actually like done something. I think I've just complained a lot honestly like Clinton did and like why is it so hot like this sucks. And then in like the kind of same light of the people putting the crosswalk you know like painting crosswalks or installing their own monitors like this might be it. This might be the most impact that we can have rather than trying to like influence the...

53:54

Five-year fiscal plan at MTA or like go to Albany and like lobby Governor Hochul to do stuff like I don't know if we have the capacity. Maybe we do, but maybe what's more in our power is to just like do this ourselves and like impact a small amount of people but make their day by giving them water, a dog drink some water. There's a lot of families. And yeah, that's sort of...

54:18

That's it. So if you have any questions, thoughts, experience during the heat wave or any rich person or foundation, once it can be money so I can think more about these things. That's the presentation. Thank you. Yeah, go ahead. How is the air quality in the subway? Yeah, sorry, I didn't really talk about the... I can't go back. Yeah, Michael, maybe you can talk about this. Oh, well, CO2? Oh, it's not too bad. It's 1,300 now, which is... It's in the subway system.

55:10

So I did some experiments with the AirBeam monitor. This middle one you can see. So like 55 to 60 micrograms per cubic meter of the PM2.5. I, at the time I did that last year, I sort of had a grasp with that, and now I can't really tell you. It seems quite bad. It looks red. Yeah, so that was in the Broadway Lafayette. That was in the Broadway Lafayette BDFM station, which I noticed has like worse air quality than most, for reasons I don't really understand. But I guess the...

55:40

There's the air quality, which... I guess I'm just a bit worried about heat because air quality does seem like worse, but I think... yeah, I don't know. I'm not really trying to say it, but that's kind of all the data that I have on that. I apologize. I have a bit more. Yeah. Well, just to give a little clarity on that, I think a lot of the air quality issues in the subway... A lot of the air quality issues in the subway stem from the...

56:10

The steel brick dust. I think. And so that's why you see like kind of like black dust all over like in the subway stations. That's just like the steel brick dust. So you're kind of breathing that in. So that's one of the like the main issues of air quality. I've also heard that rat poop gets polarized from the brakes as well. So we might be breathing that in. Okay. Yeah. Maybe. Yeah. But thank you.

56:42

Can you talk about it? I can talk about it. When you put up the data on the screen, I went to my wet bulb calculator because I was like, wait, that actually seems dangerous. Yeah, this chart. So wet bulb is... It's actually a better indicator of survivability of heat. It's a combination of heat index and relative humidity. And when those two numbers, when relative humidity is high enough relative to temperature.

57:25

Your body can no longer evaporate sweat off your skin and that is when the body starts to heat up and the heat actually starts to become dangerous for human survival. So if you spend long enough in the subway at these temperatures and these dew points, like these are dangerous wet bulb temperatures or near dangerous wet bulb temperatures. And it seems crazy to me that, like, for instance, the MTA climate people are more concerned about that. I do want to actually...

57:51

Demons I started in this video. So I've talked to the MTA, there's a climate resiliency team at the MTA. I've talked to them a lot last year. They were thinking about these things a lot. They were doing work, like there's a guy named Ricky Lee who's an engineer on that team. They were doing a lot of the work on the pilot up at Washington Heights. I just think they have like limited clout within the MTA and like a lot of decisions get made by the construction development team. But they are actually thinking about this and I think the fact that they didn't want to collaborate with me was whatever.

58:19

They're thinking about the heat a lot, but also they're thinking about it because it, I think mainly because it affects the underground infrastructure, right? So like they're thinking about it from a dollar cost. The flooding is, they're thinking about it because it ruins the equipment underground and like it causes a lot of monetary problems. That's the same for heat. It's not from like a people perspective. So that's also a question of mine. It's like how can we start to like, it has to relate to a dollar cost. So like when I'm thinking about talking to these people, it's like I care about it because it's a public health issue, but how can we make The MTA care about it. Maybe when it gets hotter in the summer, there's more crime underground and that results in more lawsuits and more dollars than MTA. So it's like constantly thinking about trying to get them to care about it and the ways they care about things while also communicating our stuff. I mean, would it be difficult to install a de-humidifier?

59:19

I'm being serious. Like, do they have outlets? And then you just buy a bunch of even out of bars and install it. I mean, a lot of what people say is like, why can't we install air conditioning in the stations, which I think a lot of other countries do, like, I'm thinking maybe like Hong Kong or China or other port of out stations. But I think the infrastructure here is like, for example, like, 42 unit square was built in 1903. So there's just like the infrastructure that's there is not...

59:46

It's all open too. The grates on the sidewalk, it's all open systems. It's not enclosed. So to make an AC system work or dehumidifier, you'd have to put screen doors everywhere. You'd have to close those. I mean, I'm not an engineer, but it doesn't seem very costly. I mean, all you need is a way to just drain the water. You don't need to pipe the heat out anywhere just to bring the humidity down. So I don't know. Next question here.

1:00:17

Yo, what's up? If a philanthropic funder gave you like five million dollars, let's say, how would you spend that money? I would go to like Mexico City. No, when I think about like what my rule in this is, it's like like awareness raising or like trying to, I think I would just, I'm good at doing weird projects like this, like installing sensors and also getting people together. Like I was able to.

1:00:55

Submit this RFI with a two or three hundred company and get all these scientists and researchers together. But ultimately, long term, I would need those resources. I need to pay people to help. That was all. No one got paid. It's a mission within itself to get people to feel engaged enough in the project that they want to help. And I have to see my passion for it, so they're excited and stuff like that. They want to be involved. But that's a constant battle, too. And honestly, I got burnt out a lot just because I wasn't getting paid. So I don't...

1:01:24

Maybe I should have been prepared for this, but I think just getting more people on board and being able to explore these ideas more and actually start a non-profit or something where we can... You think Rioters Alliance, they're doing a lot of lobbying, and I think that's what actually needs to be done, is lobbying the state because the state hires the board on the MTA and they control all of their budget, and that's a place that I've largely overlooked. I'm getting hyped when Zoran, I know a secondary connection with Zoran, he doesn't...

1:01:54

There's no control. He doesn't do anything for the MTA. That's not the avenue that needs to be taken. It needs to be Governor Hopewell. It needs to be the state legislators who control the budget. And getting more people on board with this to help push for the solutions in an efficient way. Because so far I've not been efficient. And I've been just doing hard projects. But I think there could be a much better way of approaching these issues. Anyone else for a question? I just got called out again. I'm really curious.

1:02:28

And by the way, I really love the presentation. In terms of like, the thing I think about a lot with MTA projects is public versus private, where the MTA does some things themselves, and some things that they give to other people. The MTA hires their own conductors, but they outsource the ads to Altrun. I'm curious as to how you think about the data collection for something like E or other data collection, the MTA, for things that are important to people.

1:02:59

Should those things be public? Should those things be private? Should those things be in a non-profit? And how much of that trade-off is just a reflection of the political reality we're in versus the ideal state. I think, my friend Cesario, you tried to get data from the MTA, right? MTA, I sent them a Freedom of Hoyer Act, like the Freedom of Mason Act. It took them six months to apply with...

1:03:28

They're collecting data too, I think. I know they are, because I've talked to these people who are installing sensors in the stations, I've talked to Rick Ely and the other engineers, and I don't think they want, they're not incentivized to let us go and install sensors and collect this data and around air quality and heat, because it makes them look bad. Right, like putting, it's about framing this. I think about, you know, I'm trying to get like plants in stations or like improving air quality through nature-based solutions. So like that, the constant struggle is like, how can we part, I don't want to be against the MTA. I want to work with the MTA. So how to do this in a way that makes them look good too. So through the data collection, can it be framed in, we're collecting this now, but like, come with us as we see how it improves over time through these solutions that we're implementing. Or like, we have moss walls in the stations and like,

1:04:28

You can see the air quality getting better and improving the experience for the customers too. But I think there needs to be more accountability for sure because how I see it is if there's no pressure from the outside from people like us who are just trying to do it, these solutions will happen. They will install geothermal cooling I'm sure in stations but it's going to take decades. And in the meanwhile, it's going to continue getting hotter every summer and people are going to die and nothing's going to happen. We're already, you know, there's a heat wave right now. It's the same situation as last year.

1:04:57

So, I don't really know. But, do you work at MTA? What are you doing? I am a data visualization engineer. So, I'm in our central data team. I imagine you spoke with folks on my team, I'm not sure. I'm pro-MTA. I'm not against the MTA. I think there's a... The problem with MTA, I think, is there's a... They have a problem with communication, right? Because I get all these comments online around like, the MTA is shitting money away or they're doing nothing. But if you actually talk to these people, everyone cares about this stuff. They care more about anyone to fix these issues, but we don't see that as the public. So I think there's a really large communication gap between what they're actually doing and what we see as New Yorkers, what's happening. And so I think that's a big problem too. You're probably doing amazing work, but no one knows about it.

1:05:58

Everything that like money's just disappearing, but I don't think that's the full story. You can just tell. Yeah. Who if there's like a cop that actually died, who would be liable for that? And is there a dollar amount that or an insurance company or like a legal settlement would assign to it? I don't really know. There's something called value that insurance companies and other companies used to put into this plan. I can't tell you the exact number.

1:06:53

The city self insures. I don't know if the MT does. They probably do. But that could be a number or two. What does that mean? It means they don't have an insurance company. So like for example, they just automatically settle over like slip and fall accidents. If you slip on a crack in the sidewalk, they'll just pay you. And they don't have an insurance company that does it. What if a city employee gets in an accident in a car, those drivers are not insured in the city.

1:07:27

Yeah, so they don't pay an insurance company monthly like we would as individual consumers. They just have a huge pot of money that they just pull out of because it's cheaper for them to do that. And MTA maybe is similar. You spoke about the different people who work in the subway station. I was wondering if there's any unions spoken to in terms of work conditions and temperatures. I wanted to talk to the police union.

1:08:00

and get them involved. But this was just, again, a bandwidth thing. Like, I just didn't, like, we had the capacity. There's just so many different people to talk to. But I think that's a really strong take, is to talk to the unions and the people represented. I don't know if the MTA workers are organized or if the construction workers are, if it's union workers. But, again, those are the people that are most impacted by this, right? We think about the commuters, but ultimately it's, like, it's literally the police in the stations that have to bear the brunt of this problem the most. So I think that's a really...

1:08:30

Maybe I missed this, but I was just curious what you're doing this summer. Are you still longer in the same stations or are you expanding? I think the sensors are still in the stations, but they've died. I haven't gone back for pretty much a year. I was just tired of doing it. I think this water, given that people bringing water stations are trying to get that more. I'm kind of out on the data collection stuff unless someone can...

1:09:04

Help me with it because I just don't see that. I have the secret to help you with it. I've had the scientists that I was with, we did a bunch of graphs which I didn't really show, kind of explanations of how heat exists within these stations. But all these conversations with Google and the weather company, etc. didn't discuss the actual data at a single time. It was just the idea that we were collecting data was the most attractive part. So not in a single conversation did people actually care what the data said.

1:09:34

It was more like that. We're willing to do this. I don't know actually how much it would impact more data. I'm sure I can, but I'm interested in the water, exploring bringing seeding into stations, or more interventions like that. Okay. But I'd be happy to talk to you. Pass it up to him. Just keep the question answers for him, then we'll get everyone. Sorry, I have no questions, but...

1:10:06

The first one you mentioned comparative study. You mentioned other places have platforms to ignore and stuff like that. And that is also one of the most common things people bring up in MTA, TikTok comments like, oh my god, Hong Kong or New Delhi or Tokyo has such a good system. But I think it's kind of an unfair comparison because ADA would not permeate a lot of the stuff that the system has.

1:10:27

So did you look into a bit more of a fair comparison? Like London is also known to have a very hot system. Their underground is also equally old like New York City. So maybe if they have people collecting data or something like that, if they have a solution. I know their newer lines are much better, but the older lines are still much similar to the New York City Subway. The second thing I want to bring up was, did you ever think of a solution in terms of, like if we just had like insanely high capacity, like the train running much more frequently?

1:10:56

just like we are doing having better signaling systems and stuff like that so then you just wouldn't be on the platform then or like having the the screen outside of every single exit showing when the train's coming so you just don't go inside until you're expecting a train to be there because a lot of those are just like out front ads and not showing you when the change actually coming i was just with my friend this last week they're improving the signal right now and i think that's a big i don't know if you know about it There's CBTC on the 7 and the L.

1:11:28

Yeah. But they're trying to do it for other nights. So surely that will make waiting for the trains shorter. Much shorter. And also, the way it's usually terrible in eight nights where the issue is much less, I guess. See, I mean, these issues are beyond my knowledge. And I'm just trying to approach it from the things that I can understand. But obviously, the MTA is working on signaling and the geothermal, which I think are good long-term solutions. But again, it's like, how long do these things take? And do we just suffer in the meantime or do we wait?

1:11:58

Tens of years to actually see this stuff happen. I think that's my concern. Here's a question. Alright, I'll send it back. You all have a question here. Do you know if that is here, but not a separate power grid? Or is it shared with the city? I have no clue. I'm assuming it's clear. What? I think it's here. They have their own substation network for Con Ed. With Con Ed? Yeah. That's the answer.

1:12:44

I was going to ask at energy. Are you still looking into... I mean the MTA is... There's a thing called Transit Tech Lab. I don't know if you've heard of that. It's basically like an incubator for... It's like an incubator that gets fed into helping city agencies. They are actively... Transit Tech Lab and the MTA are working on a pilot in those two stations. 168th and 181st, I'm pretty sure. You should write Ricky Lee's name now. He's really good.

1:13:25

So they're thinking about it. I'm just not. I'm not a part of that process. But the MTA is absolutely piloting solutions in a select number of stations. But then if that works, you know, the pilot works, they got to get the funding. And all these processes take a very long time. So I think it's just a matter of like, if it works, what's the feasibility? But yeah, they are. I just don't like the details. Go ahead. Have you thought about packaging this as a consumer app that...

1:13:58

people pay for based off of the sliding scale. What? Like packaging the data that you have. Oh, the data? Yeah. Like the Oasis, like the water bottle lab. I've thought about it, maybe like a year ago, but again, it's like, I don't have, there's too many avenues, and I'm like one person, so it would be cool to create that based on the data, but like, it just hasn't been a priority. And also, like, the data collection was like a sort of cool V1 thing where I like, But it's not a feasible long term solution. I don't have a permit to do it. So to actually send this data and make an app out of it, I would need to be able to do it more legitimately and actually live stream data on more of the stations. So that's a massive problem that I have to hurdle that I don't really feel like spending time on right now, to be honest. What's a good idea? I have some more ideas off of that. Also do an email. Email me. I'll find you. Yeah. Yo, and that's right here.

1:14:56

Going through your experience to the MTA and all the stuff you have done, do you think it's finally a good idea to privatize the MTA? No. You said you had 70s temperature probes. Can you comment on whether you calibrated it either to each other or to an external standard? The loggers came with a certificate that they would be good for a year. So after a year you have to recalibrate, you can send it back in to recalibrate, but I didn't do it myself, but it came, I mean they're like a legit company. I can imagine these thermometers that are just available online, they're very reactive, you know, I'm concerned about that. I know some other sensors, particularly the VOCs and the carbon dioxide.

1:15:52

It tends to drift over time. Yeah, I think after a year it starts to drift more than like closer on these typical degrees. I actually got two, a cheap one from Amazon and an expensive one from Amazon and they were surprisingly similar. Oh, that's awesome. So I put them right next to each other and they were within a couple points. I went home and like sometimes it gives me wild readings and I have to like turn it back on to home again and take some time to calibrate. I'm just like, wow, this is wildly inaccurate and I do not trust it.

1:16:24

Thinking about leveraging your skill for creating a community around this stuff and momentum, I'm curious what data you think the common person would be able to collect and give to you through their phones, their wearable devices, or anything if you were to ask people to do something to collect data, what would it be? So I wanted to crowdsource, and this is kind of why I was excited about this, is getting more people, why people...

1:16:50

DMing me all the time asking how they can volunteer and I never have any clue how someone can help. But it does seem like a crowdsourced data collection where we all go out for a day and disperse throughout the whole subway system and collect heat data or air quality and make it a crowdsourced effort rather than one person going around. But again, I just don't know. I'm more and more pessimistic the effect of that. And then we'd have to package that data and lobby a state legislator and say, I just don't want to do that, really. But I think it could be a cool experiment.

1:17:20

And I would love to. I just need help to collect the stuff. I need the devices. I need an organization or a university to give me 100 devices and these cost a lot of money. And so just thinking about the logistics behind it have stopped me from doing it yet. But yeah, I'd be interested in exploring that more for sure. Have you considered writing an op-ed or taking a heavier press approach because this is, I don't know, like 50 people?

1:17:52

You can get in front of millions of people if you found the right editor or publication. And I'm sure that there are many climate reporters or environmental reporters who would probably love to work with you. Whether it's covering you or if you were to sort of write about this whole experience, I think it's fascinating and I'm sure a lot of people would want to read it. Could you somehow figure it out? I got you. No, it's like I'm trying to, I have so much, only, I'm only into so much stuff, so like the writing, the piece, like.

1:18:23

It takes time and energy, so I just haven't gotten to it, but I think it's a good idea. Have you considered emailing the Google Maps team and telling them to integrate this data into Google Maps? So instead of just showing how we can train this, we can show how out of station is and the air quality, and then computers can make wrong choices. So not emailing them.

1:18:54

public projects team but just emailing the google maps team directly like on linkedin i'm like yo i have an idea just see what they think i haven't done that but it could be good yeah i'm like emailed out i'm like tired of emailing basically is where i'm at so I'm not sure if you said this before I arrived, but what was the hottest and coolest stations that you reported on average? We can wrap up Sand 2 and Apur. Who else has a question? I have some quick data from the results. So Hudson Yards was the coolest. It average 81 degrees Fahrenheit throughout the summer. And that's because there's actually cooling technology within the station. It's one of the nearest stations that do some type of passive cooling. And 168 Street had the highest.

1:20:00

Heat index of 103. Both surface and subway are closer at 5 AM, but the surface peaks at 2 PM, but the subway peaks at 6 PM, allowing that to be rushed. That might be with the amount of people at the stations, or it just takes more time for the heat to manifest. I thought this was interesting. In June is actually the hottest time on the surface, but it takes until later in July for it to actually heat up within the stations.

1:20:29

It's not a one-to-one relationship. And the subway station, so 40% less variance than the surface, but at a higher baseline. So the fluctuates less in temperature, but actually is hotter. So that's just kind of interesting stuff, but I've never actually used that to make a point. Last question. Sorry, thanks for the talk. I was just wondering if you might be willing to make your cacheable data public. Awesome. Yeah, thank you.

1:20:57

Well, I thought about putting on a GitHub repo, but because I was trying to commercialize the data last summer, I was like, I kind of wanted to keep it, which is also reasonable. But maybe I'm sort of done with that. And I think if there was, like, people, you know, people are interested in data visualization or whatever, I'd be, and I'd be happy to, if you just want to email me, I could just, like, maybe give you a private repo about data or something like that. Yeah. Thank you, everyone.

1:21:30

So if you're around after, come speak with Jack and send an email if you want to get involved. And thank you all for coming. The RFP closed in October. How do we perceive heat? That's why this metal board is not a problem. That's my issue. Basically, this wood and this piece of metal might be at the same temperature. Similarly, your potential speed depends a lot on your metabolism, your size, your person, your genetics, but also just like your psychological speed. SSRIs get affected.

1:33:06

I love putting you on the school. After graduating, I have been wanting to be my son with more. I've heard you ask a couple of questions. Were you at the Benibus? I'm going to go next Friday. I've been there once, but I've found it on going to the NYC. I didn't go there for that but I saw it. I mean, I've not been there in a couple of years now.

1:35:15

I grew up in my home and I mostly never left the same. Have you ever heard of Daddy Chalk? The hot place. You know what I'm talking about? Because I was going to say, you know what name is different? Daddy Chalk is the craziest case. It's like, that was the basketball that took four times the size of the square. I don't know. People are going to die over here. We're going to die.

1:36:38

yeah yeah yeah The First Day is the only place on the page. I'm gonna head out. Do you want to go tell any trends? Yeah. Do you want to do the bump or? What are you guys trying to do? There we go, finally. I think it's got like nearby share or beans. I used to have a... I think you're supposed to be like do this. It's been a couple of years since I've been here. It's been very hard to see. The funniest thing that happened is that one of my closest friends friends is in Delhi. Today we were talking about all streets among the world.

1:38:59

Delhi. I grew up there. I love Basan Bihar. Because of the pedestrian only. Basan Bihar is where the Bhoji people live. He's staying with his girlfriend in Gurgaon. Gurgaon was supposed to take the overflow in Delhi. Now Gurgaon is overflowing. I don't take it on a train but it's the one train that goes to Gurgaon or something. It's so bad. It is the yellow train. Air line. Used to go to Buddha City Center. And then it connects to Rapid Hotel. All of them. I don't know if it's called Rapid Train. I don't know what it is. But it's like... You know why it's called Buddha City City Center? Buddha. Yeah, H-E-D-A. Korean Urban Development. Right. But because the chief minister at that time was Buddha.

1:39:53

Goelia is also called something something industrial. New offline industrial. That choice was made for that reason. That's funny as well. They're building the S-Bahn system. S-Bahn? S-Bahn? S-Bahn. Expressways, right? No, no. The train. RER in Europe. Oh, they go to the city. RTS. How much faster are we doing? Pretty fast. But if it has fewer stations, do you know those second degree, not half the transit, but like stops every year and stops every year and stops? Okay. Long at a degree, but faster. Okay. So long at a degree, but every hour of the company. Only thing I hear about usually is how much load they have constructed. Are they constructed?

1:40:51

I went to Spencer. My brother was telling me. They kinda have to, but there's no other option. Are you planning on going back to school? I'm thinking about it, but I'm not sure. I feel like afterwards, if you're pretty passionate about this, you're ready to do it. The thing is, you don't have that many opportunities to understand. I was going to say, I'm not a small thing.

1:41:21

I know someone else. The guy runs the NYC. He works in the NTI. Or the other route is going to academia. Yeah, yeah. That's what I have to do with the ASI or the ASI. Yeah. Is the ASI or Street View? Street View. Where at? Here? Yeah, at Cornell. I've been here for 10 years. I know, I don't understand if you're in ASI at Cornell. I forgot what it's called, like biochemistry or something? Yes. It works at NASA. Wow. That's crazy. I don't know anybody who works at NASA.

1:42:05

I'm doing a little bit of video. But at the end we didn't go to the corner. It's something biochemistry I think. And now working in NASA. That's more than ISS. I have a friend living in the green street format right now. Oh, who? Like right now? It's with whom? I don't know the right now. He just started. Yeah, I didn't know who he did. I've been thinking of him. I do know something with other people. We're very good from the States.

1:43:05

What are you doing? What for? Underground. I'm going to do Underground. UMass. They have a very good polymer physics department that used to be somewhat adjacent to my area. Polymers. Motivus is also very good. I mean, I'm... It is metallurgy at ISM Dunbar. It is metallurgy. He's like, last two letters of money. I love it. I like how the name is. I like teaching. I like the hat. I just cover it up. It's a good hat. I have some shitty merch. Is there fun on post-foc rally? A post-foc nationality? It's a little company. I don't know why they need this. It's usually a bad guy. Name's after a hedgehog. Oh, yeah. They're the hedgehog. Oh, okay.

1:44:35

I'm a designer. I've been like working with more than a grand school for data analytics. I'm interested in data, but I'm interested in like resources. I'm really interested in like hostile architecture. Yeah, those are like the most iconic versions of them. And I would say like also architecture really like, it shapes our whole city. New York City in a lot of ways is kind of like this symbol of hostile architecture really like leading the way. What are some?

1:45:17

I'm going to go to the next video. What are some examples? Um, okay, you know those like chairs that are like, yeah? Yeah, yeah, yeah. I mean it's all the seating. There's skateboard moves. Yeah, yeah. They also have the bench for the trains. And the leaning benches. Yeah, yeah, yeah. You know, that you lean on. There's some on the workforce. But also Hustle architecture is like the disappearance of the city. Like for example, the new trains have the seating of the... It's actually crazy.

1:45:48

I wanted to go and measure the square foot. It's because it has more doors so there's more people. You know how the doors are wider also? I think that's like part of it, but I think part of it is also like... Like, who has the right to a city? You know? I think a lot of people, like, um, I think that's a very popular term that comes up a lot when you're researching a class of architecture. It comes up a lot on social media. Everybody loves talking about third spaces. So that's... You know how neoliberalism loves to ruin everything? In a lot of ways that's actually repackaged neoliberalism and people don't know what the fuck they're saying.

1:46:49

So, the concept of third spaces was literally created by this white racist dude. His definition of a third space is like a dive bar where men can be men. And in parentheses it's really white men can be men. And the counterpoint to third spaces, because ultimately third spaces are advocating for businesses. They're not public. Well, people don't realize a library is not a third space. A third space is a business. A library is a public space. That's different than a third space. And so there's this idea called the right to the city. The right to the city is like, do you have a right to like...

1:47:35

I think part of it, it wasn't just technical, it didn't just start as hard as it was. It's across all social media and it has a lot to do with that. What are you thinking about Bob? I think they're okay, but ultimately... There's a lot of, not just public spaces, but the city does own a chip load of real estate. You can see it online, it's about hospital architecture through the graduate center and they have a panel. One of the women works for this organization that they literally like...

1:49:07

The city has, like, parks, let's say, spaces that are designated for parks, and it's just, they never do anything with parks. But it is a lot of, like, typically owned spaces that we just have never used to be. And I don't know, I mean, it's a very, like, techno-fascist thing to do, like, live-scoring in private spaces and privatize everything. Like, that's kind of why we have Waymo.

1:49:32

And Waymo is trying to overtake the muscles. And it's just like, at what point did we stop shoving video cameras and grabbing like, every button? Like that's like part of it, you know? Um, yeah. I don't know, when somebody suggested earlier today like, do you want to privatize the NYC? That is insane. No. I'm guessing that was a video. Such a tech... That's like the ultimate goal. PM2.6 is like 5, 10 minutes of a living night. That is a problem. The career should be. Oh, the same guy. Yeah, it is not. It's already kind of personalized. Like it's owned by a company and that company is owned by a company.

1:50:19

And that fund, actually they run the new OMNYC. Remember we got the new system? Omni. So they already run the system in San Francisco and then they run it in another city and it was Washington and R.L. So venture capitalists come for us all unfortunately. But there is a big reason why the fair got put up and also they took away a bunch of things. We used to have a weekly pass, a monthly pass, a 24 hour pass. We don't have any of that now. It's a rolling window. I think it's a good opinion for some people but some people are not in the crowd.

1:51:03

I like that. I think that there's... $3 is very cost prohibitive for $3. It's on the record. People can interview that. There's lots of free options. It's a very progressive system. Because usually if you live in the Bronx, there's another part of the world. It would be like 10 hours to get home. But here, most of you can get affected by the show. So, sometimes you'll be like, oh, like five minutes, right? And you're done. But most of the world is like distant face rising. You know, and then the zones. The zones, yeah. The zones are insane. You're made like 15 hours.

1:51:58

I was gonna say though I think we're like Any kind of engineering, like data cuts. If you're thinking about schools, I know it's something that's like, prestigious, but it is an amazing tool. Check out the kind of thing. CUNY has a really good school. Oh, cool. Okay, yeah. The CUNY system is like, incredible. When it comes to urban planning, just like, a lot of the professors there, like, they're really amazing. They're regular school. Cool. City nerd. City nerd.

1:53:05

It's amazing. I'm thinking of going. Do you think it's on the basis? I'm gonna walk. Yeah, I might go at... On the walk? Yes. I'm thinking of registering. I'm not like 100% sure I'll be free, but it's also free so I'm just like... I want to see. I've never actually been there. You don't know why I've never been there? Because there's no transit to go there. Say that! How about you make a bar that nobody can get to? I am extremely pro-boosting versus such a constrained sort of thinking like, oh we are building it here just because they're haze, like already in fact. Because it's different, it's just like 4 and a half billion dollars. I think they need to attack the point that it's not that much.

1:54:32

They're saying it's fine, it's more than me but it's gonna bring in more money. That's true. But normal people are like, they don't know that like... I know. Yeah, they're pretty good. They're horrible. No, they're pretty good for like normal people. Normal people are not as smart as you. You need to tell them to be deaf. An effective communicator is someone who can get to the most part of people. Queensland people are pretty good at food. They also have a lot of money. Every summer what I usually do is I explore the city of the city. In the winter I'm kind of in urban areas and I just go to many places. In the summer right now I'm going to walk a lot, random neighborhoods of the city, try random food.

1:55:26

I'm trying to go through the end of every train line if possible. But I feel like I can finish the documents. I can feel like maybe I can go to the office and finish that up and then also go to the Twinsday. Twinsday? Yeah, I think that could be nice. Harder. Harder. I can do the A all the way. I took the D to Norboot 205. I took the Staten Island to Thottenville. That was the toughest thing. I have gone through this in 10 years. In 10 years? Oh. Actually, probably in 10 years. I can recall when I was there. We've never been on Saturday. You're the only one. What's the first time I did? My odds are not.

1:56:16

That is impossible. How the heck? You never go to North? No. I go to Little India a lot. I go to Little India. I go to Little India. I think he's got a little Daps and Mites. But that is not Little India. That's like Little Bambu. That's okay. I have no other brothers. Yeah, I have no brother who's there. I'm like, the turtle square has like actual food. In Jackson Heights, all the food shops. Really? Except, I mean, all the food. Indian posing food shops. I mean like all the Tibetan food is good. I mean like, have you ever heard Mahalada? Mahalada, where is that? It's like Mahalada, where are the students? In Jackson Heights? I don't remember the names, but I'm probably a fan of England. England is good, I'm not being there.

1:57:01

I'm not sure, these are just like regular Indian restaurants that exist everywhere right? In journals fair you have like street food, you have like all the crazy kinds of things that you can have. In normal India you go like okay, you order like curry and rice, oh my god. It's like just really good. Angel is not my W. I'm sure it's like good, I'm not saying. I love other food which I like a lot but sometimes like I want other stuff yeah there's like a lot

1:58:00

but it's like $50.00 budget. It's kind of expensive. I've never been there because I have. It's sort of like, it's sort of just a standard Goodraver. I think, I have something that's very different. Like in Goodra, there's micro-Business. That sounds like standard Goodra, which is fine, but I've just never found myself, I don't want to go there, but I've just never been there. I think it's a little bit expensive, but I'm wanting to go to Edison. I haven't actually walked around to this very much.

1:58:36

I love Punjabi Spires here. It's one of my favorite places in the UR. It's very easy to miss because it's like a taxidermy. Actually the funny thing is like two years ago, three years ago... I was visiting a friend who was doing masters at Portland Tech. So you know the other ones? Yeah, so we went to the place that used to be in the place of Punjabi friends.

1:59:08

It was called Delhi's Pines and some other Indian made, also like a fixed never had one. It sucked, it was really bad. And then in the future I ended up in Punjabi. Have I been here before? There's like new owners or something like that. Punjabi's Pines is great. Punjabi's Pines is awesome. My photo is like, it's like glowed in my eyes. Yeah, oh my god. Perfect. Let's let exchange Instagram if you like. I should go home by the way. I'm actually thinking of going to...

1:59:37

Because they have like Tatyawari food from my region of Gujarat. The peninsula in the Gujarat that looks like a... The run up clutch? So that's the...below that, the peninsula. You know that sounds like Somnath and... I mean, Gujarat has like this sort of a shape. I'll just show you. But basically within Gujarati it's very different. So obviously there's like Kachifu, my mom is from the country. And then this is the Swarashtra or Kachiavara. And then this is like North and this is like I guess Amdavan surrounding is the dominant Gujarati culture. So what then I have to do over it to actually like at that point I could just literally do anything. I want Hanli.

2:00:26

Oh, that you can find in journals. Oh, in journals we have, in India, everybody is good. So you can probably find that. I think that's what I've heard. It's very good. There are some good South Indian Indian South. I like Dosa's a lot. So there's Ganesh Dosa's is very good. Pratibular is like Bangalore Stratusa and Ganesh Dosa's is like Tamil Stratusa. I can give you that.